Don’t Trust Calorie Counts—19% Are Wrong

Don’t Trust Calorie Counts—19% Are Wrong

New York City : NY : USA | Jul 20, 2011 at 8:01 AM PDT
Views: Pending
Weight and Self Esteem

If you’ve been counting calories in an attempt to lose weight, your efforts may be pointless, especially when trying to account for restaurant foods. Researchers from Tufts University analyzed 269 meals from 42 restaurants, and found that a whopping 19% of dishes had at least 100 more calories than advertised. No wonder some foods seem almost too good to be true—they probably are not.

The study found that sit-down restaurants, as opposed to fast-food chains, had higher rates of inaccurate labels, most likely due to a less regimented food preparation; extra salad dressing or varying amounts of mayonnaise can significantly change the calorie content of a meal. The USDA estimates that people eat out about three times per week, and the extra calories could contribute to weight gain. Leading researcher Susan Roberts said, “a hundred extra calories a day is not inconsequential . . . it adds up to about ten pounds of extra weight a year. “ She added that the worse calorie discrepancies tended to be with salads, soups, and side dishes.

Federal law states that restaurants with over 20 locations must have calorie information available. And FDA regulations say that packaged food may contain up to 8% more calories than advertised, while chain restaurants can be up to 18% wrong.

Linda Van Horn, Ph.D. of Northwestern’s Feinberg School of Medicine said that more problematic than inaccurate calorie counts is the fact that not many people even consider caloric information before ordering food, nor do they know how to use that information to their benefit. She said, “All the labeling in the world isn’t going to help if people don’t know what they need.”

Maybe we should rely less on numbers and more on common sense, if we cannot even trust the numbers. Calorie-counting is maybe even outdated anyway, according to studies saying that we should focus more on nutrient density of foods rather than how low in calories they are.

Do you count calories? Are there any restaurant foods you’re suspicious of?

Elizabeth415 is based in New York City, New York, United States of America, and is a Stringer on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Calorie counts found lacking

      Moreover Silicon Valley
    Posted calorie counts in chain restaurants are often inaccurate, and weight-conscious consumers who select soups and salads are especially likely to be served heftier dishes than advertised, according to a new study from Boston researchers. Their...
  • Restaurant Calorie Counts Inaccurate: Study

      International Business Times
    Human Nutrition Research Center at Tufts University which conducted the study, says the lowest calorie options on menus at many restaurants throughout the country are on average 100 calories higher than what is promoted on menus Interestingly, the...
  • Healthy restaurant dishes pack more calories than expected

      USA Today
    Updated If you're watching your weight and eat out frequently, proceed cautiously. That healthy soup, sandwich or entree may have 100 to 275 more calories than the restaurant says, according to a new study. Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging at...
  • One in 5 restaurant calorie listings is off

    You think you're being smart when, in an effort to eat more healthfully, you check a restaurant's website to see how many calories are in a dish you plan to order. It turns out perhaps that effort isn't worth as much as you think. A new study by...
  • Some Restaurant Calorie Counts May Be Inaccurate

    Most posted calorie counts for restaurant foods are generally accurate, but there can be big discrepancies, especially at sit-down restaurants, according to a new analysis. The study shows that overall the posted calorie counts for foods at 42 fast-...
  • Calorie Labeling at Restaurants May Hold Surprises

      Fox News
    But a new study shows it might be hard to know exactly what that is, because calorie labeling at chain restaurants can be deceptive. Across dozens of restaurants in three states, researchers found the stated calorie counts were accurate on average,...

More From Allvoices

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.