U.S. Justice: Is A Jury System Effective Or Do We Need To Revise It?

U.S. Justice: Is A Jury System Effective Or Do We Need To Revise It?

Washington : DC : USA | Jul 05, 2011 at 3:49 PM PDT
Views: Pending
Casey Anthony Defense: Caylee Drowned in Pool

July 5, 2011]------The verdict in the Casey Anthony murder trial has ignited a firestorm of opinions on her guilt or innocence despite the jury's 'not guilty' decision.

Looking at our current system where a jury of our peers sit in judgement of us if we are unlucky enough to end up in a courtroom, one can't help but feel a tad uneasy.

Looking at the Casey Anthony's case, that unease is heightened to downright panic, depending on which side of the table you're sitting.

12 ordinary folks are asked to make life and death decisions sometimes, for we have the death penalty on our books. That is a daunting task and for some, bewildering and overwhelming.

Throw the defense and prosecution cunning maneuverings and legal wranglings-- vying to capture, outsmart, twist and subvert each other-- then add the constant 24 hour news cycle that reaches its tentacles everywhere and one wonders just how unbiased and 'fair' are many verdicts.

The law as it is written, is very complex and many of us have scant knowledge of its intricacies yet are asked to sit and decipher legal language, forensics, technical terminologies, nuances and come up with an intelligent synopsis.

Some cases drag on for weeks, in Anthony's case, six weeks. Another infamous trial, which took up a great deal of our time, with everyone glued to the television--was the O.J. Simpson's case. Like Casey's trial, this one too garnered some intense opinions.

When cases are this volatile and jurers are sequestered, they can suffer from physical burn-out and mental fatigue from the stress of it all. Prosecutors and defense teams are also affected by this pressurized atmosphere and mistakes may be made trying to perform for the public audience. The stakes tend to be higher for many times reputations are made or broken in these high profile trials. Trying to get a verdict that the public clamours for can make the D.A.'s office over-reach for the maximum charge, which can then backfire.

Is that what happened in Casey's and O.J. Simpson's trials?

Whether we want to admit it or not, color, class, gender, money, education and intellect all come into play during trials and can inadvertently or blatantly influence trials and therefore verdicts.

There have been recent cases where African American men have spent up to an unbelievabe 30 years behind bars, most of them on death row for crimes they did not commit. In one case, the state of Texas is adding insult to injury by refusing to pay compensation for wrongful imprisonment. The prosecution withheld key evidence and threatened and co-erced witnesses and was himself never charged for misconduct.

Numerous cases of injustice have slipped through the U.S. Justice system and more often than not, race and class play an enormous role. Studies have found that Africa-American defendants are sentenced more harshly for the same crime than Caucasian defendants. Which makes me wonder--if Casey was an African American mother, would she have gotten the same 'not guilty plea?'

Another thing that also stands out to me is the swearing on the Bible. Witnesses are always asked to 'raise their right hand and swear to tell the truth, nothing but the whole truth, so help me God." Now really, is this the best way to get people to tell the truth or is this an archaic rule that definitely needs throwing out?

We do not all believe in "God.' There are atheists among us, plenty, in fact. Moreover, there are a number of other religions practiced in the U.S. where the 'God' of the Judeo-Christian Bible and faith is not present. Even folks who believe in God, will lie without compunction, with both hands and feet firmly planted on the Bible.

So just how effective is our U.S. Justice system? Do we need to revise it and if so what can we put in its place?

1 of 3
The U.S. Justice System
Examining the U.S. Justice System: does it really work or do we need to revise it?
VeronicaS is based in New York City, New York, United States of America, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Casey Anthony -- Verdict REACHED

    The jury has reached a verdict in the Casey Anthony murder trial ... and will announce their decision from the Florida courtroom at 11:15 AM PT. Anthony is accused of murdering her 2-year-old daughter Caylee in Florida in 2008. According to one legal...
  • Casey Anthony's Attorney: I Saved a Life Today

    Casey was acquitted by the Florida jury of murder and child abuse charges and convicted only of lying to police. She could be released from jail as early as Thursday depending on what sentence she is given in the lesser conviction. "Caylee has passed...
  • Casey Anthony could go free after 3 years in jail

      Miami Herald
    Jury clears Casey Anthony of murder charges Jury clears Casey Anthony of murder charges A case that involved years of forensic investigation, weeks of often highly technical testimony and untold hours of media analysis turned out to be pretty...
  • Casey Anthony acquitted of murder

      USA Today
    The jury of 7 women and 5 men in Orlando did find the 25-year-old Anthony guilty of giving false information to a law enforcement in connection with the case. The jurors returned the verdict after more than 10 hours of deliberation...She hugged her...
  • Casey Anthony trial: Hundreds flock to Caylee Anthony memorial as jury ...

      Mail Online UK
    Police stepped up security at the Anthony's home as the jury came one step closer to a verdict. No parking signs were placed from the memorial site to the Anthony home, which is a few blocks away. Memorial: Hundreds of people started descending on...
  • Casey Anthony Verdict: Sheriff Asks Residents to Remain 'Peaceful'

    Instead, Orange County Sheriff Jerry Demmings had a plea for the community. "As the verdict has been rendered, we ask our community to respect the decision the jury and court have made today," Demmings said of the surprising not guilty verdict . "...


  • lomyrnosound: casey anthony trial live online

    casey anthony trial live online. images Casey Anthony Trial Live casey anthony trial live online. Casey Anthony#39;s murder trial; Casey Anthony#39;s murder trial. praveenuppaluri. 09-03 11:27 AM. I am not a congress supporter and I am ...
  • throplisniqua: casey anthony trial photos of caylee

    images casey anthony trial crime casey anthony trial photos of caylee. Casey Anthony broke down in; Casey Anthony broke down in; wallpaper Casey Anthony broke down in casey anthony trial photos of caylee. orl-casey-anthony-caylee- ...
  • timbplanacen: watch casey anthony trial live

    watch casey anthony trial live. images Internet Viewers Watch Casey Anthony Trial Live as watch casey anthony trial live. Casey Anthony Trial Photo; Casey Anthony Trial Photo. LookingForGC. 06-29 10:42 PM. Thank You! It helps. ...
  • bilemanvers: casey anthony trial live

    casey anthony trial live. images Crowd for Casey Anthony trial casey anthony trial live. In Casey Anthony Trial; In Casey Anthony Trial. rsdang. 08-22 05:47 PM. that the years for Citzenship count the day you apply for I-485...not ...
  • puchondlanni: casey anthony trial photos of caylee

    casey anthony trial photos of caylee. images Casey Anthony trial: Witness casey anthony trial photos of caylee. Caylee/Casey Anthony Case: Caylee/Casey Anthony Case: viswanadh73. 12-10 10:32 AM. congratulations on approval of I-140. ...
  • jhonmatchondci: casey anthony trial live coverage

    casey anthony trial live coverage. images Casey Anthony Status Hearing A casey anthony trial live coverage. of the Casey Anthony trial; of the Casey Anthony trial. wandmaker. 12-03 11:33 PM ...



More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.