Taliban: Obama's Afghan Strategy Failed
Local to Global News
 
 Connect 
Sign up now!

Taliban: Obama's Afghan Strategy Failed

Kabul : Afghanistan | Dec 17, 2010 at 5:01 AM PST
8 0
Views: 962
 
Taliban presence in Afghanistan

The Taliban dismissed President Obama's Afghan/Pakistan Strategy as a failed strategy, stating it has failed both militarily and on the civilian administration fronts.

Zabiullah Mujahid said, in an e-mail, the last nine years of war have proven that increased troop levels have no effect on the outcome.

"It is a failed strategy, not only on the military side but also in civilian and administrative affairs," he said. "Public services in Afghanistan have failed. Corruption, insecurity and also the civilian casualties are a result of failed American strategy."

"President Obama is also talking about progress, but it is clear for everyone that the reality is completely the opposite of what he says," he added.

President Obama unveiled his Afghan/Pakistan Strategy Review yesterday. He said that some progress had been made and that the Taliban and Al Quaeda momentum has been halted and that the insurgents had suffered grievous losses.

Obama emphasized that further progress will not come easily. Success is largely dependent on Pakistan's effectiveness of eliminating insurgents and the training of the Afghan National Security Forces.

The President also said that the transition phase would commence in 2011, with a complete handover to Afganistan's Security Forces by 2014.

In their response, the Taliban claimed that the exit or withdrawal of U.S. troops is not the result of success but rather an effect of increased U.S. casualties and the cost of the Afghan war, which the U.S. can no longer afford.

Mujahid vowed that the Taliban would continue the fight agains coalition forces. He said that "with the presence of foreign forces in our country there will be no peace and security. The interference of foreign forces in the affairs of Afghanistan ... will only increase casualties."

While NATO officials believe they have weakend the Taliban, it must also be pointed out that, as a rule, the Taliban do not fight during the winter months. The proof will be in the pudding, sort to speak, when the fighting season restarts this spring.

The transition phase, which is to start next July, is also contingent on conditions on the ground. The Taliban will certainly look to exploit NATO's public perception of this war and continue its strategy of IEDs, car bombs and infiltration of Afghans Security Forces.

Mullen: eliminating Pakistani safe havens is key
Back
1 of 2
Next
Troops on Footpatrol
Footpatrol - Awareness of Dangers caused by IEDs a Must

Karl Gotthardt is based in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, and is an Anchor for Allvoices.
Report Credibility
 
 
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
 
 
Advertisement
 
Posted By northsunm32 northsunm32 | over 1 year ago
A fair summing up of the situation. The Taliban seems to be extending their range in the north while the actions in the south have at least temporarily weakened the Taliban and extended Afghan and NATO control temporarily. However if Marjah is any indication the U.S. will need to maintain a presence and the Afghan forces are not able to control the occupied areas. An earlier negotiation makes more sense for all sides. But it seems not to be. Look for more antiwar demonstrations.
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 1 year ago
This is the traditional time when the Taliban rest for the winter season. I agree that NATO Forces will have to provide cover for the Afghan Security Forces for some time.
Posted By DavaCastillo Dava Castillo | over 1 year ago
Thanks for the report Karl.

I wouldn't expect anything else from the Taliban, and I agree they will exploit NATO's position.

As in the past, Americans against wars hold a tremendous influence over Washington when demonstrations escalate, and Congress people will be going home next summer and have to face an unhappy constiuency who for the most part will be against continuing the war. Perhaps the July draw down is suppose to ease this event, but then like you said, it all depends on events on the ground if that date is valid.
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 1 year ago
Insurgencies by their nature are very difficult to fight. In Iraq it only worked, after the Suniis decided to join the fight against the foreign insurgents. That in essence provided the change. Prior to that there was a real chance of a civil war in Iraq.

Afghanistan is not Iraq. A lot has been accomplished on the development end of the scale, albeit only in secure regions. It would be heartbreaking to see it all go for naught.

The biggest problem here is that once in a while a piece of candy is being thrown at the public, and Ken actually describes that well in his newest story. What is missing from the whole scenario is a clear definition of the end-state.
Posted By RaulDeSouza RaulDeSouza | over 1 year ago
We all know this I think by now Obama knows this too so then doesnt he calls the troops back?
Posted By BorderExplorer BorderExplorer | over 1 year ago
Thanks, Karl. Mainstream media in the U.S. seem to surpress this message, promoting false optimism instead. It is great to see reality in your report.
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 1 year ago
Thanks for commenting Billie. The public needs a real dose of reality. Personally I expected more from the strategy review of this war yesterday.

As an example:

a. Where is the progress and how is it measured?

b. What is the state of the Afghan National Army and Police and what can they reasonably expected to do?

c. What areas will become the responsibility of the Afghan National Army and a timeline.

d. After a handover in those regions, what happens to NATO troops previously responsible for them? Do they leave the theatre? Do they provide back-up? Do they move on to another role in Afghanistan, like training or assisting NGOs and other Aid Agencies.

e. How will government work in Afghanistan? Will it remain centralized or will there be a larger effort to go regional, which actually makes more sense.

I think you see where I am getting at. The Review yesterday gave very little detail and was really worthless overall.
Posted By robertweller Robert Weller | over 1 year ago
The mainstream media even events or distorts words: militants is my favorite. the fact is there are many more insurgents than the taliban. or just people who are pissed off. so call them militants since so often no one knows who they are. surge is another great one. we used to use offensive. but of course in some cases the additional troops stay in urban areas or behind the wire. and i do not mean to demean their courage because it is beyond question.
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 1 year ago
The grunts certainly are not behind any wire. Of course logistical troops operate from there, but they are often out on CLPs (Combat Logistic Patrols). Being away from home for 12 to 15 months at a time is not exactly pleasant either, especially if it's already your third or fourth tour. You watch your family growing in stages.

There are a lot of difficulties with what we put our troops through. You're in a war zone one day and the next day, you're supposed to act perfectly normal in American society.

Meanwhile the relationship between you and your spouse has also changed.
Posted By Punditty Punditty | over 1 year ago
The Taliban got it wrong - Obama never even *had* a strategy in Afghanistan.
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 1 year ago
Amen. Good Comment Punditty.
Posted By BMcPherson BMcPherson | over 1 year ago
Most of us now recognize the plight of women in Afghanistan. When it is worth your life to give birth to a child and some faceless foreigner kills it with little more acknowlegement of "collateral damage" what can the mother do but be your enemy. I would be your enemy. Don't tell me about democracy and freedom when you kill my kids. The killing of civilians must stop or there will never be peace.
Reply By DavaCastillo Dava Castillo | over 1 year ago
Barbara

There is a great documentary called "Motherland Afghanistan." It's available from netflix.

Afghani-American filmmaker Sedika Mojadidi shadows her father, a women's health specialist working to rebuild hospitals in war-torn Afghanistan, in this thought-provoking documentary filmed in the wake of the United States' invasion of the region. In a country where one in seven women dies during childbirth, many women are willing to travel for days to receive adequate care from a trained professional.

The damage to Afghan medical community never recovered from the Russian Invasion. This documentary tells the story without being sentimental, yet speaks to the heart of medical care for women in Afghanistan.
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 1 year ago
Thanks for your comments and the recommendation of the documentary. There is no doubt that women have suffered for a long time in Afghanistan. Abandoning them, which we may, will make the situation only worse.
Posted By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 1 year ago
If that comment is made, it is only fair to also talk about the Taliban and others that oppressed women and girls, conduct stoning, decapitations, throwing of acids into faces, public floggings, etc, long before NATO showed up.

Let's not forget the human shields the Taliban uses for publicity purposes.
This war leaves a bitter taste in my mouth as well, but I think both sides of the story need to be told. The Taliban aren't exactly your model citizen when it comes to implementing their rules and will.

Our troops can and will be held accountable, the Taliban and other insurgents are not.
Advertisement
 

News Stories

 
  • Taliban reject Obama war strategy review

    AP Online
    Afghanistan (AP) — The Taliban on Friday rejected the review of President Barack Obama's year-old war strategy in Afghanistan, saying that it has failed on both the military and the civil administration fronts. In an e-mailed statement,...
  • Taliban reject Obama war strategy review

    The Boston Globe
    Afghanistan The Taliban have rejected the review of President Barack Obama's year-old war strategy in Afghanistan, saying that it has failed on both the military and the civil administration fronts. Taliban spokesman Zabiullah Mujahid said in an...
  • Mullen: Taliban hideouts can be shut down

    Taiwan News
    The top U.S. military officer said Friday that he thinks it is possible that the Pakistani military can shutdown Taliban hideouts on its soil to prevent insurgents from moving back and forth across the long, porous Afghan-Pakistan border.
  • U.S. Revises Guidelines For Afghan Night Raids

    Fox
    In this photo taken with night vision, a U.S. soldier looks through his gun during a night patrol in eastern Afghanistan. U.S. military command in Afghanistan has revised secret guidelines for nighttime raids, placing additional safeguards on kill-or-...
  • Barack Obama: Afghanistan war is on track

    The Guardian
    The first full-scale assessment of the president's troop surge strategy said the deadline to begin withdrawing coalition forces from Afghanistan next year will be met because of successes in reversing some of the gains made by the Taliban and against...
  • Obama says Afghan withdrawal is on track

    USA Today
    With the review out of the way, the next major test of the strategy will be in the spring and summer when the traditional fighting season gets underway. "You're going to see in the spring time how well we're doing or how badly we're doing," said Sen.

Blogs

 >
  • Mariah Carey sings for President Obama (video)

    Submitted By: CelebrationMadonna | 7 months ago
    Back on the Billboard 200 Album chart, Mariah's new album isn't selling well compared to Taylor Swift and Susan Boyle. "Merry Christmas II" You has managed to get sold around 300k copies in the US and struggled to reach a Gold status. Her 1st Merry ...
  • Taliban say U.S. Afghan war review is propaganda | Geo436

    www.geo436.com
    U.S. President Barack Obama”s review, released on Thursday, found NATO-led forces were making headway against the Taliban but serious challenges remained. It said the insurgents” momentum had been arrested in much of Afghanistan and ... But Taliban

Images

 >
 

Videos

 >
 
Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

 
Tap_logo_330_103

Sitemap


Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc 2008-2012. All rights reserved.