RP TV Network issues views on the hostage-taking crisis in Manila
Linkedin

RP TV Network issues views on the hostage-taking crisis in Manila

Manila : Philippines | Aug 26, 2010 at 1:39 AM PDT
XX XX
Views: Pending
 
Radio Philippines Network - Metro Manila TV Stations

"Media's job is to tell the story, but no story is worth even one life." This is how the ABS-CBN looked at the hostage-taking coverage that took more than three days to cover. In fact the incident continues to draw stories and coverages.

Here is the full statement:

"We will always cooperate with authorities in trying to resolve complex situations like the Aug 23 hostage crisis.

If the government had called for a news blackout, ABS-CBN would have supported it.

We are done with an initial assessment of our coverage and continue to review our policies.

We exercised self-restraint on Monday:

1. We refused to air the hostage taker's threats live about a 3 pm deadline to avoid fuelling public fear.

2. We refused to air the hostage taker's interview until after negotiations were finished.

3. We refused to be part of hostage negotiations.

4. All throughout the day and until the first shots were aired, we kept our cameras 400 meters away from the bus, giving us shaky video that viewers complained about. Our teams never crossed the police line.

5. Although we had access to members of the police reaction team, we held back interviews which could compromise their plans and/or location.

6. After the police tried to arrest the hostage taker's brother, our team physically stepped back to comply with police request.

7. After the assault began, we tried to limit our shots to avoid showing police movements. We stayed with extreme close-ups or wide shots.

8. We immediately complied when police asked us to turn off our lights explaining the grainy shots viewers complained about.

9. We avoided tampering with evidence at crime scene. Instead, we asked Soco to shoot the video instead of entering the bus ourselves.

This wasn't enough.

We acknowledge airing a report that detailed the position of the police during the assault.

During the arrest of Gregorio Mendoza, we considered pulling away from the coverage but a man was crying for help.

In other countries around the world, governments set the ground rules for situations like this. One network cannot unilaterally declare a news blackout. Press freedom issues take a back seat during situations like this - where the government already has the power to define the terms to media.

We are taking the public's views to heart. Monday's tragic events triggered intense soul-searching for us. Such is the irony of a profession that wields so much power but relies entirely on self-doubt to gain --- and keep --- its credibility.

We ask our broadcast colleagues to join us in an industry review. Let us unite and work together to put in place measures to collectively decide when we stop live coverage in the absence of government presence of mind."

Well said. I personally veered away from the particular news coverage, even if I knew it would have earned me many things other than monetary values.

I have yet to process my attitude towards such gory coverages, like that bus crash in Benguet the other week. # Lyn V. Ramo

lynspace is based in Baguio, Cordillera, Philippines, and is an Anchor for Allvoices.
Report Credibility
 
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
 
 
Advertisement
 
Posted By RobertWeller991 RobertWeller991 | over 2 years ago
I have no way of knowing whether what they say is true. But this is a good story. As a long-time journalist I have seen the notion develop that the media has NO choice and must run things ... because if they don't others will. To me there always is a choice.
Reply By lynspace lynspace | over 2 years ago
Thanks for your comment Mr. Weller. We in the mass media really have to learn our lessons and learn them well.
Posted By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | over 2 years ago
I fully agree with you. Even CBC decided to stop live coverage at a point during the negotiations and only provide edited taped versions. There is a point when you have to consider what is in the interest of public and what is in the interest of the hostages. In this case someone should have known that there was a tv on the bus. Someone was acting without the full information available.
Reply By lynspace lynspace | over 2 years ago
Yes, Sir. Sometimes we have to decide and make the right decisions, especially in times of crisis in the coverage. I have yet to experience these times.
Posted By Voiceparker Voiceparker | over 2 years ago
A very tragic incident Indeed.Pray that those life rest in peace.
Reply By lynspace lynspace | over 2 years ago
Thanks for reading between the lines. it is really the life of people that we are here for.
Posted By paretta paretta | over 2 years ago
Whaat a harrowing experience for the hostages. The media has penetrated so much of society that it almost seems that it is there even before the news breaks. It's sort of likethe O.J. situation every day! Media canbe a "double-edged" sword. Thanks for the report.
Reply By lynspace lynspace | over 2 years ago
I will prefer to stay on the side of the people, although I have yet to experience what more seasoned journalists have done.
Posted By matbaron1974 matbaron1974 | over 2 years ago
I'm a Filipino and i am very sorry for what the hostage taker had done,
and for those who are taking pictures in front of hostage taking,
i think that they don't know what they are doing,
it's not a drill but it was real a real nightmare.
but now a know that they are ashamed and asking for forgiveness,
i know that this kind of tragic moment is so hard to forget,
no one wants this to happen,
we also care for those people who died so bad in the hands of terror,
now we're putting our foot at the same shoes that you are wearing right now
and it felt so bad it hearts me so much,
i feel pain like the pain you've caring,
it's not the color that matters but a life that we'll miss.
may God bless all those soul and may God rest them in peace.

peace be with us
Reply By lynspace lynspace | over 2 years ago
It is unethical for us to earn from other peple's misery, but then it is also our job to deliver the news, which means delivering it with no life as a payment.
Advertisement
 

News Stories

 
  • ABS-CBN to RP press: Let’s collectively decide when to stop live coverage

    Inquirer.net
    PhilippinesBroadcast network ABS-CBN on Thursday stressed that it exercised self-restraint in its coverage of the bus siege on Monday, even as it acknowledged that it reported the detailed position of policemen as they attempted to storm the bus with...
  • Hostage-taker’s brod to be charged with disobedience

    Inquirer.net
    PhilippinesThe brother of slain hostage-taker former Senio Insp. Rolando Mendoza is to be charged with serious disobedience for his role in the bungled negotiations during Monday's bloody hostage crisis, the Manila Prosecutor's Office said Wednesday.
  • Gregorio Mendoza’s ‘arrest’ now a question of semantics

    Inquirer.net
    PhilippinesThe investigation into who ordered the arrest of SPO2 Gregorio Mendoza, the brother of slain hostage-taker former Senior Insp. Rolando Mendoza, is turning out to be a question of semantics...Orlando Yebra claimed that nobody, not even...
  • Mayor ordered hostage-taker’s brother arrest—Manila police chief

    Inquirer.net
    It was Manila Mayor Alfredo Lim who ordered the arrest of the brother of the dismissed policeman who held hostage Hong Kong tourists in Manila last Monday that resulted in the deaths of eight tourists, the citys chief of police told a Senate...
  • CMFR urges media to resist legislated news coverage

    GMA News
    Philippine media organizations must resist current calls for legislated ethics in covering the news, particularly when lives are at stake, by addressing their own shortcomings in light of the botched hostage rescue on Aug. 23 in front of the Quirino...
  • Police failed to bring gas masks—official

    Inquirer.net
    Philippines Police failed to bring their masks when they used tear gas in an attempt to rescue Hong Kong tourists who were held hostage by a dismissed officer who took over their bus in Manila Monday, an official admitted before the Senate Thursday.

Blogs

 >
  • HOSTAGE TAKER, EX-COP ROLANDO MENDOZA DEAD, 4 VICTIMS KILLED AFTER ...

    www.pinoyhalo.com
    Manila hostage crisis ended after 12 hours on Monday night while heavy rains pour with the hostage-taker, former Police Senior Inspector Rolando Mendoza, dead after he was shot in the head by a sniper of the Philippine National Police ... The
  • Jibrael Angel 2 Blog (Eme Esber Blog): Bloodbath in Quirino ...

    jibraelangel2blog.blogspot.com
    The Manila hostage crisis occurred when a dismissed Philippine National Police officer took over a tourist bus in front of the Quirino Grandstand in Rizal Park, Manila, Philippines on August 23, 2010. Rolando Mendoza (10 January 1955 ...
  • Hostage-taker killed as drama ends | TV Natin - Free Online Pinoy ...

    tvnatinto.blogspot.com
    In a separate press interview, Superintendent Nelson Yabut who was part of the 30-man assault team said they were initially unable to enter the bus because Mendoza had the hostages lined-up and leaning on the bus windows. .... The incident brought
  • u2r2h blog: "RELEASE FINAL DECISION" - Manila Bus

    u2r2h.blogspot.com
    Gunfire rang out moments later before local and international television cameras. "I shot two Chinese. I will finish them all if they do not stop," he told Radio Mindanao Network. Troops then stormed the bus. .... Along with Mendoza's wife Aurora,

Videos

 >
 

More From Allvoices

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

 
Tap_logo_330_110_event
 


Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc 2008-2013. All rights reserved.