Crime Without Punishment

Crime Without Punishment

Smolensk : Russia | Apr 10, 2010 at 1:00 PM PDT
Views: Pending

Katyn Forest Tragedy Lives On With Death Of Polish President

Murderer Rodion Romanovich Raskolnikov, one of literature’s most famous villains, was created by Russian author Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky.

And with him the moral dilemma of how to expiate one’s guilt. Raskolnikov, in “Crime and Punishment,” ultimately turns himself in and is sent to Siberia where he may one day find redemption.

How can the weight that the former Soviet Union bears, in just one case, the Katyn Forest massacre, be lifted off its collective back if it won’t even apologize? No matter how much Vladimir Putin tries to absolve Russia of its guilt because it was committed under its previous name.

On Saturday, a plane carrying Polish President Lech Kaczynski and dozens of other senior military and other officials were killed near the site of the massacre en route to a memorial for the 22,000 Polish officers and intelligentsia killed in the spring of 1940.

Also among those on the plane was Ryszard Kaczorowski, Poland’s president in exile during the Cold War.

Soviet leaders had admitted responsibility for the massacre in 1990, but even this week, at an earlier ceremony, Putin stopped short of apologizing. It was part of a strategy to make sure Poland would be easier to control once the war was over.

“Prime Minister Putin, the eye sockets of those killed here by a shot to the back of the head are looking at us today and waiting to see whether we are ready to turn this lie into reconciliation,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk said to the Russian prime minister. Tusk was not on the plane that crashed Saturday near Smolensk.

No one has been prosecuted for the killings, blamed by Stalin’s government on Hitler’s Germany, though how the Nazis would have managed to kill so many Poles deep inside Russia was never explained. Putin’s attitude could be compared to Germans saying they couldn’t be blamed for what Hitler did.

Indeed, Russia has a long history of suppressing Poland. In 1831, Frédéric Chopin, wrote his “Revolutionary Etude” about a Polish attempt to break free from Russian control. Despite several victories they ultimately had to surrender to the vastly larger Russian army.

The Russian people this week also had an opportunity to see the unvarnished truth about Katyn when a film made by Polish director Andrzej Wadja, winner of an honorary Academy Award for his work, was shown on national television, albeit the culture channel.

Wadja’s father, a cavalry officer, was among those killed at Katyn.

The film, available on the general market with English and other subtitles, is titled “Katyn.”

The film tells the story of both the murdered and their families, desperately seeking definitive word of what had happened to their loved ones.

It begins with Poles fleeing Germans encountering their countrymen trying to escape Russians. Stalin had taken advantage of the German invasion to seize a portion of Poland under a secret agreement with Hitler.

When the two invading armies meet they are shown as friends celebrating their victories.

At the heart of the story is a Polish family: a mother, her university professor husband, her Polish army captain son and his wife and daughter.

The wife, learning that her husband has been taken prisoner by the Russians, travels across Poland on a bike, dragging a second one, hoping to persuade him to discard his uniform and flee. He refuses because of his patriotic duty, and ends up among those with a bullet in the back of the head.

The professor ends up dead in a Nazi concentration camp.

The wife, in her own way, also refuses a possible escape route. A Russian captain living in the same building with her offers to marry her, warning her that Stalin has ordered the wives of all Polish officers killed.

“Once I wasn’t able to save my own family,” he tells her, assuring her that he soon will be headed to the Finnish front and has no amorous intentions. He also tells her that her husband and all the others are dead. It is too late by then, in any case, as the Russian soldiers arriving looking for her within minutes. He hides her long enough for her to escape.

Like other Poles, Anna (Maja Ostaszewska) waits five years to learn what has happened to her husband, listening to announcements in public squares of confirmed deaths. Because he is not on a published list her hope keeps her going.

Ultimately, a former Polish officer who has joined the Russians, arrives to tell her that her husband is dead. The two had swapped sweaters and thus the mistake.

By now a major in the Russian army, Jerzy Porucznik (Andrzej Chyra) has decided it is better to be alive. When criticized for abandoning his comrades, he says he can’t tell the truth. “I might just as well shoot myself in the head.” Later he does.

The killing in Katyn hasn’t been shown yet, but the film flashes ahead to the war being over. Even then the family members of victims are not permitted to speak the truth about the true killers.

The executions in Katyn end the film, with the director spending a mercifully brief time on them.

Documentary film made by the Germans, when they found the bodies during Operation Barbarossa, and by the Russians, perhaps some of the same film taken by the Germans, is shown.

1 of 4
RobertWeller991 is based in Denver, Colorado, United States of America, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • CBC News - World - The Katyn massacre: A crime without punishment

    Submitted By: albertacowpoke | over 4 years ago
    : Thursday, April 8, 2010 | 12:20 PM ET Seventy years after the Katyn massacre, Russia and Poland have made a substantial effort to redress their enmity over a war crime committed during the opening stages of the Second World War. But there's still ...
  • Plane Crash in Russia: Tragedy for Poland

      Salem News
    A large contingent of high ranking Polish civilian and military leaders were killed this morning in a firery crash at an airport near Smolensk in Russia. Among the dead is Lech Kaczynski, Poland’s president who was en route to a memorial to honor...
  • Analysis: Katyn claims another Polish generation

      AP Online
    Poland (AP) — He died en route to the most sensitive mission possible — a visit to the place that has driven a wedge between Poles and Russians for three generations. The death of Lech Kaczynski, Poland's president and dozens of his...
  • Plane crash kills Polish president

      The Daily Star (Bangladesh)
    The ageing Russian jet was taking Kaczynski and his wife, the military chief of staff and other top officers, central bank governor, deputy foreign minister, members of parliament and other senior officials to a ceremony for thousands of Polish...
  • Russian leaders express grief over Polish tragedy

      Daily News & Analysis
    Polish president and his wife were among the 97 people onboard the presidential Soviet built Tupolev Tu-154 jet, which crashed in dense fog this morning. "On behalf of the Russian people I express deepest, most sincere condolences to the Polish...
  • Polish President killed in plane crash in Russia

    Polish President Lech Kaczynski and a high-level delegation were killed when a plane carrying 97 people crashed in thick fog as it was approaching a Russian airport on Saturday morning. Russian authorities said there were no survivors in the...


  • Tragedy Upon Tragedy As Polish Leadership Killed
    Just days ago I wrote about the Katyn Forest massacre, and the hopeful sign that for the first time the Russians and Poles were commemorating that tragedy together. For the leadership of Poland to die en route is a tragedy upon tragedy: ...
    A historic meeting was scheduled between top leaders of Russia and Poland in April 2010. It is believed that it will provide new details about Russia's mass execution of 22000 Polish officers in the Katyn forest in 1940. ... Among those are President
  • Poland ETF in Focus After President's Death |
    The presidential party was en route to a memorial service for Poles massacred by Soviet troops in World War II when its Tupolev Tu-154 airliner crashed in thick fog while approaching Smolensk airport, in the west of Russia.The disaster sent Poland
  • A thing you might keep in mind « Glew
    The delegation was to attend an anniversary ceremony commemorating the murder of thousands of Poles killed in the spring of 1940 by Soviet forces under Josef Stalin at the Katyn forest, close to the city of Smolensk. Russia Today: Polish Tragedy…
  • Remembering the Katyn Massacre › 2.0: The Blogmocracy
    A Russian plane crashed near Smolensk, carrying the President of Poland, Lech Kaczyński, his wife Maria, and dozens of senior Polish officials. They had been returning from a ceremony at the site of the Katyn atrocity, for which Russia finally ... in
  • Who Wants to Kill President of Poland in a Plane Crash !
    Chief executive Lech Kaczynski's aircraft attempted to land in the thick fog, missing the runway and snagging treetops about 50 % a mile from your air port in Smolensk, scattering chunks of flaming fuselage across a bare forest. ... Mr. Kaczysnki,





More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.