Allied forces ‘may abandon most of northern Helmand’

Sunday, November 8, 2009
November 9, 2009

by Nasra Ismail and Biodun Iginla, BBC News Senior Analysts

*

Recommend?

A new strategy for Afghanistan that could lead to a British troop withdrawal from a former Taleban stronghold in northern Helmand province sparked immediate controversy yesterday.

According to a senior Nato source, Western military commanders in Afghanistan are considering a radical shift in policy that would see British and US forces conduct a tactical pull-out from most of northern Helmand, including the town of Musa Qala. The source said that the plan to withdraw from northern Helmand would be considered if proposed reinforcements, currently being examined by President Obama, were not approved. General Stanley McChrystal, the US commander in Kabul, has asked for 40,000 more troops but President Obama has yet to make a decision.

British military sources said, however, that a withdrawal from Musa Qala would be viewed as a defeat and could not be countenanced. They said it would also be a betrayal of the governor of the district, who risked his life to take a stand against the insurgents.

Mullah Abdul Salaam, a former Taleban commander, switched sides to become district governor of Musa Qala only hours before British troops from 52 Brigade and Afghan soldiers retook the town from insurgent control in December 2007. British troops had withdrawn from Musa Qala in 2006 after a “deal” with the local tribal elders, but the Taleban seized control until the arrival of 52 Brigade.
Related Links

* Afghans have waited eight years for security

The plans now being considered in Kabul would pull British and American troops out of the towns of Musa Qala and Nawzad to focus on stabilising the highly populated central areas of the province. The only remaining Western forces in the north of the province would be those defending the hydro-electric dam at Kajaki.

The plans are the most radical among options being considered by General McChrystal under a broader plan to shift forces towards the defence of more populous areas of the country, ceding outlying and remote areas. The new doctrine is focused on concentration of forces around population centres, main arteries and economic corridors with the ultimate aim of protecting the population and allowing intensive reconstruction.

A senior Nato officer confirmed that proposals existed for a pull-out from Nawzad and Musa Qala, but said: “No decision has been made.”

The senior British military sources insisted that total withdrawal from Musa Qala was not an option but acknowledged it was possible that the area in which troops currently operated in the district could be reduced to make available more resources for enhancing security in places such as Kandahar and Lashkar Gah.

Air Chief Marshal Sir Jock Stirrup, the Chief of the Defence Staff, also denied that Britain was planning to pull out of Musa Qala, but he confirmed on the BBC Andrew Marr show that Nato’s International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) would be focusing more on Afghanistan’s main population centres.

A Ministry of Defence spokesman said: “Focusing on people, not territory, is not a retreat, it is the strategy set out by the Prime Minister in April and by General McChrystal in his recent review of strategy for Isaf. Nevertheless there are currently no plans to withdraw from any area of Helmand.”

US forces in eastern Afghanistan have already begun withdrawing from a number of combat outposts, mostly in remote areas close to the porous Pakistan border. Lieutenant-Colonel Todd Vician, US Army spokesman, confirmed that US forces have so far withdrawn from six outposts, four in Nuristan province and two in Paktika province.

Brigadier James Cowan who commands 11 Light Brigade in Helmand, denied that British troops might withdraw from outlying towns in the province. “We are here to protect Helmand, we have no plans whatsoever to withdraw,” he said.

* Print

* Email

Bookmark and Share
Your Comments

(Displaying 1-10)

Order By:

* Newest first
* Oldest first
* Most recommended

Report item as: (required) X
Comment: (optional)
have your say

Would you like to post a comment? Please register or log in
Login
Register
Report item as: (required) X
Comment: (optional)

* Terms and conditions

Ads by Google

Free Maps & Directions
Get Instant Access To Maps& Directions w/Maps Toolbar
Maps.alot.com

How to make Electricity
A shocking new homeowner's kit thepower co's hope you will never own
www.Power-4-Homes.com

In the News:
Bloodiest Battle In World HistoryWatch TV Feeds Online!
www.russiatoday.com

Also in Afghanistan News

* Allied forces ‘may abandon most of northern Helmand’
* Stanley McChrystal’s strategy faces an old problem — convincing the locals
* Army wants to retreat in Afghanistan

Also in World News

* Security van driver leaps to celebrity after speeding off with £10m
* Pigs don't fly: Air Zimbabwe plane crashes into bushpig on runway
* Cleveland mayor’s niece lived with Anthony Sowell, suspected 'Cleveland Strangler' Posted by BiodunIginla at 10:44 PM Labels: al-Qaeda, BBC News, biodun i ginla, General McChrystal Afghanistan, NATO, Obama, taleban 0 comments:

Post a Comment

Links to this post

Create a Link

Older Post Home Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)