Muslim American Victim Mentality

Muslim American Victim Mentality

Killeen : TX : USA | Nov 08, 2009 at 1:21 PM PST
Views: Pending
Psychologist on Fort Hood massacre

As I'm analyzing the reaction of the Muslim American community to the tragedy at Fort Hood, I feel like they are living in a wholly different universe than the rest of the country. 13 people were murdered, and they did not deserve their fate. Dozens were injured, and they did not deserve it either. But the community leaders and representatives of the Muslim American community are focused on only one thing: the fear that the entire community will be linked with the Fort Hood tragedy. It is a legitimate concern, of course. But fears are overblown. Most Americans are able to differentiate between ordinary citizens who happen to be Muslim and terrorists who happen to be Muslim.

There are irrational folks on the right-wing blogosphere who are blaming the Fort Hood shootings on the Islamic faith, but these right-wingers are pretty much the only ones. So I'm curious about one thing: if the Muslim American community is trying so very hard to distance itself from the shootings, who is the primary audience? Is it the rational center or is it the irrational right wing? If the former, then the Muslim American community is preaching to the choir; however, if it's the latter, then it's a hopeless endevaour because no amount of PR will convice the far right that Islam isn't an evil faith.

I believe that instead of wasting their efforts by saying, "We're Americans too. Please don't blame us for this tragedy," Muslim Americans should instead have expressed a greater deal of sympathy for the victims of Fort Hood. The victims of the shootings are the real victims of this tragedy. Muslim Americans are not the victim so they really should stop trying to portray themselves as the victims. And at some point, they should probably try to get over the victim mentality that they have had since 9/11. Yes, Muslim Americans did suffer after 9/11. And it was sad and totally unjustified.

But at some point, you gotta move on. 9/11 was 8 years ago. The country is in a different mood today. Aside from people like Brian Kilmeade, Gretchen Carlson, Debbie Schlussel, Michelle Malkin, Pamela Geller, there has not been a whole lot of Muslim bashing in the United States due to Fort Hood. Moreover, many Americans may likely be offended by the Muslim American attempts at assuming the victim status. I'm a Muslim Canadian, and even I'm offended by the statements being made by Muslim Americans regarding Fort Hood. The people that truly deserve our sympathy are the families of those that died at Fort Hood. If Muslim Americans really want to be seen as real Americans, it might be helpful if they focus less on themselves and more on their fellow citizens who are suffering in the aftermath of this terrible tragedy.

1 of 1
President Barack Obama will attend a memorial service at Fort Hood Tuesday
US Army Specialist Ryn Hill (R) and his daughter Emma, 3, place flowers and a candle for victims of the shooting at Fort Hood, at the main gate. Investigators on Saturday worked to uncover the motives of a Muslim US army doctor suspected of killing 13 people and wounding 30 others in a shooting rampage at the US military base.
Saad Zafar is based in Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Muslims brace for backlash after Fort Hood shootings

      Chicago Tribune
    Muslims proclaim their praise five times a day by raising their hands and declaring "Allahu akbar," or "God is great" -- the same words Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan is reported to have uttered before the Fort Hood shooting rampage last week. Bracing for a...
  • Fort Hood and the new McCarthyism | HA Hellyer

      The Guardian
    Fort Hood and the new McCarthyism Although Muslims are some of the US's most loyal citizens, this terrible shooting will be used as evidence that they are innately un-American The Fort Hood shootings will likely reverberate across the media for...
  • “Devout Muslims – danger for American security”

      Russia Today
    But, he asked, “how can we tell the difference between those that do represent a threat, and those that do not?” Last week's shooting incident at Fort Hood in America left the nation in shock. Some analysts have highlighted the idea that the man...
  • Muslim Group Starts Fund for Fort Hood Victims' Families

      Fox News
    Ind.  —  An American Muslim group says it has established a fund to benefit the families of victims in the Fort Hood shootings. The Islamic Society of North America announced Monday that it's collaborating with other Muslim organizations and...
  • Obama salutes 13 Americans; says no faith justifies killings

      Daily News & Analysis
    We come together filled with sorrow for the 13 Americans that we have lost, with gratitude for the lives that they led, and with a determination to honour them through the work we carry on," Obama yesterday said addressing a crowd of 15,000 soldiers...
  • Obama honors 13 killed in shooting at Fort Hood
    President Barack Obama participated in a memorial service at the Fort Hood Army base, Texas, Tuesday to honor 13 people killed by a U.S. Army psychiatrist.     Obama honored the men and women killed in Thursday's shooting rampage for their service,...







More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.