Allvoices.com - Vietnam Books Playing Key Role in Afghan War De...

Vietnam Books Playing Key Role in Afghan War Debate

Vietnam Books Playing Key Role in Afghan War Debate

Posted by: RaulDeSouza

Vietnam Books Playing Key Role in Afghan War Debate

A pair of books on the Vietnam War—one on why America should never have gotten involved, and one on how it could have won—are providing the framework for the Washington debate over Afghanistan strategy, insiders say. Lessons in Disaster, which describes how the White House was pushed into an "unwinnable" war by the military, is being read in the West Wing, while A Better War, which describes a military that has figured out how to counter an insurgency just as it is forced to end the fight by politicians, is on Pentagon reading lists. A Better War, which argues that American intervention in Vietnam would have succeeded if the strategies employed after 1968 had been used from the outset, helped convert many skeptics on Capitol Hill in 2007 ahead of the surge in Iraq. Opponents of increasing troops in Afghanistan now say Lessons in Disaster neatly sums up their concerns. Both books, the Wall Street Journal notes, have been flying off the bookshelves in DC so fast it's now tough to find a copy of either one.

Reach

Credibility

Related Allvoices Contributions

Obama aware of Afghan differences

By: genius-world

US President Barack Obama has said his decision on a new strategy in Afghanistan will not please everyone. He told key figures from Congress, gathered to discuss future US plans, that he would decide on a course of action with a sense of urgency. Democratic Senator Harry Reid said members from both parties told Mr Obama they would support his ...

2 months ago
President Barack Obama will "not cut-off" U.S. troops in Afghanistan

By: spike-breaker08

According to BBC news, U.S. President Barack Obama said his review of Afghan strategy will not look at pulling out or cutting troop level.As both Democrat and Republican parties where invited in the White House to talk over the said "cutting-off or pulling out" U.S. troops in Afghanistan, Obama told key members of Congress that he sense the ...

2 months ago
Ignoring the math of disaster: political folly

By: Africanjade

Whether in Kabul, London, Washington or Pretoria global leaders appear to believe that big mouth is more important than sound math. Let’s take the United States and the United Kingdom. Battling with two wars in Iraq and Afghanistan – the latter of which seems to be getting hopelessly out of control and endangering Pakistan and ...

27 days ago
Obama Faces 'Moment of Truth' With TV Address to Nation on War in ...

By: SkeeterVT

President Said Repeatedly During '08 Campaign That BushBushBush's War in Iraq Was a Distraction From the 'Real War on Terror' in Afghanistan and Is Shifting U.S. Resources Accordingly -- But He Risks Alienating His Hard-Core Anti-War Supporters Who Voted for Him Amid Sharp Divisions in Public Sentiment on Wh

6 days ago
- 1
- 2
- >

News Stories

High end of troop request for Afghanistan: 60,000-plus

News Source: Christian Science Monitor | about 1 month ago

Stanley McChrystal included an option to send at least 60,000 more US troops to Afghanistan...Stanley McChrystal's troop request for Afghanistan includes an option to send at least 60,000 additional American forces to buttress the war effort there...
Arrest of 61 Peace Activists Outside White House Kicks Off Week of Protest ...

News Source: Democracy Now | 2 months ago

Dozens of rallies and protests are being held across the country today. We speak to David Swanson, who was among 61 people arrested Monday at a protest outside the White House.
President rules out cutting Afghan troops

News Source: Sydney Morning Herald | 2 months ago

Death toll ... the body of a US soldier arrives home this week. At a White House meeting aimed at tempering the increasingly politicised debate over the war in Afghanistan, the US President, Barack Obama, told congressional leaders he does not plan...
Obama's Afghanistan options: bad, worse and worst

News Source: The Guardian | 2 months ago

Yesterday's White House roundtable on the war in Afghanistan does not sound as if it made the critical choice facing Barack Obama any easier. The president was able to rule out a rapid drawdown but that was never really on the cards in any case.
Obama mulls middle ground in Afghanistan war strategy

News Source: Los Angeles Times | 2 months ago

At a White House meeting aimed at tempering increasingly politicized debate over the war in Afghanistan, President Obama told congressional leaders Tuesday that he does not plan to dramatically reduce the American troop level or switch to a strictly...
Amid Afghan Policy Debate, What About Pakistan?

News Source: National Public Radio | 2 months ago

The debate on Afghanistan has riveted Congress, the Pentagon and policy-watchers as the Obama administration reviews its current strategy. Following a dire assessment of the situation in Afghanistan by Gen. Stanley McChrystal, the top U.S. commander...