The leading source for credible citizen reporting

Report Your News
Take the tour...

Germany seeks Afghan raid answers

By: farhat96 send a private message
Munich : Germany | 3 months ago  
Views: 6
  • Germany seeks Afghan raid answers
    Germany seeks Afghan raid answers
    Posted by: farhat96
    Germany seeks Afghan raid answers
  • A US Army Blackhawk helicopter in Logar Province, Afghanistan
    A US Army Blackhawk helicopter in Logar Province, Afghanistan
    Source: AFP
Germany seeks Afghan raid answers

German Chancellor Angela Merkel has called for an urgent investigation into an airstrike in northern Afghanistan, amid tension about who was to blame.

In an announcement with UK PM Gordon Brown, she also said a major summit on Afghanistan should be held this year.

Reports have suggested that civilians were among the dozens of victims of Friday's German-ordered raid.

Ms Merkel said if any civilians died in the Kunduz province strike, she would "naturally deeply regret that".

The British and German leaders said the meeting should focus on helping Afghanistan take on more responsibility.

Mr Brown said it should "deal with the issues of security, governance and development".

The BBC's Steve Rosenberg in Berlin says although they did not spell it out, what the politicians are concerned about is the urgent need for an Afghan exit strategy.

That is what most of the German public wants to see as Nato's mission in Afghanistan is unpopular with them, our correspondent adds.

Britain has about 9,000 troops in Afghanistan and Germany has some 4,200.

Exit strategy?

Friday's airstrike was called in by a German commander after Taliban rebels hijacked two fuel tankers.

The raid has caused uproar in Germany, which will hold parliamentary elections on 27 September.

Speaking in Berlin on Sunday, Mrs Merkel said a quick investigation was essential.

"The German government and I personally want to see a Nato investigative team swiftly put together that will carry out a thorough and quick explanation of what took place and whether there were civilians killed," she said.

Germany has 4,200 troops in Afghanistan

Her comments came as the Washington Post reported that the German commander who ordered the raid may have done so in breach of Nato rules.

The German commander ordered the airstrike after seeing live footage of the tankers, with people around them, beamed from US aircraft in the skies above Kunduz.

The footage would have been grainy, US spokesman Rear Admiral Gregory Smith told the Associated Press news agency.

The Germans, who also spoke to an informant at the scene, decided the people were militants.

German Defence Minister Franz Josef Jung said "it was clear that our soldiers were in danger".

"I stand clearly behind our commander's decision," he told German broadcasters, AP reported.

The Washington Post reported that using a single human source for intelligence appeared to breach guidelines aimed at reducing civilian deaths. Coalition officials in Afghanistan denied that any conclusion had yet been reached.

Nato has said the investigation is still ongoing, and the US commander in Afghanistan, Gen Stanley McChrystal, on Saturday promised a full investigation into the air raid.

Latest poll results

The Berlin news conference came hours after the latest partial results from Afghanistan's presidential election were released.

They showed incumbent Hamid Karzai within touching distance of the 50% threshold needed to avoid a run-off ballot.

With three-quarters of votes counted, he had 48.6%, followed by Abdullah Abdullah with 31.7%.

The 20 August poll has been marred by allegations of widespread fraud.

Meanwhile, a Swedish charity has alleged foreign troops entered its hospital south of the Afghan capital Kabul, smashed doors and tied up staff and patients' relatives.

The Swedish Committee for Afghanistan said the soldiers came into the clinic in Shaniz in Wardak province late on Wednesday "without giving any reason or justification".

The charity said it breached agreements between non-governmental organisations and the International Security Assistance Force (Isaf), which along with the US has more than 100,000 foreign troops in Afghanistan.

An Isaf spokesman said an investigation had been launched.

  • Print
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Stumbleupon

Related Allvoices Contributions

News Stories
 
  • News Source: Gulf News | 3 months ago
    Prime Minister Gordon Brown's spokesman said the conference might be split into two parts, with one part held in Kabul, security permitting, and another part held in a "major international city" yet to be decided. "We have offered to host [the...
  • News Source: Sify News | 3 months ago
    The German Defense Ministry pushed back hard Monday against foreign criticism of a deadly German-requested airstrike in northern Afghanistan and said it remains confident its commanders acted correctly. Berlin has faced criticism for calling in...
  • News Source: The Daily Star | 3 months ago
    In a second phone call to a Times reporter in Kabul, Farrell said he and his captors heard helicopters approach before the dramatic rescue. “We were all in a room, the Talibs all ran, it was obviously a raid,” Farrell said. “We thought they...
  • News Source: Zee News | 3 months ago
    Karzai passes key 50% mark in Afghan vote, recount ordered Kabul: President Hamid Karzai has extended his lead in Afghanistan's fraud-tainted elections, for the first time passing the key 50 percent threshold needed to avoid a run-off with nearly...
  • News Source: The Frontier Post | 3 months ago
    Chancellor Angela Merkel rejected on Tuesday criticism of a deadly air strike in Afghanistan instigated by Germany and called for an agreement this year on how to transfer responsibility for security to Afghan officials. Addressing parliament three...
  • News Source: The independent | 3 months ago
    Angela Merkel says she 'deeply regrets' the loss of innocent lives The German Chancellor Angela Merkel has rushed to defend her government's military engagement in Afghanistan in the wake of a Nato air strike last week that turned into the deadliest...
Blogs
 >
  • Blog Source: www.longwarjournal.org
    More than 90 Taliban fighters and civilians are reported to have been killed in a NATO airstrike in a region under the control of the Taliban in northern Afghanistan. Germany insists no civilians were killed in the attack, however. ... 4, 2009: A
  • Blog Source: www.huffingtonpost.com
    German colonel Georg Klein is pictured at the German base in Kunduz, Afghanistan, Sunday, Sept. 6, 2009. An airstrike ordered by a German commander Klein and carried out by U.S. fighter jets that appears to have killed Afghan civilians .... The
  • Blog Source: warvictims.wordpress.com
    Tagged: Afghanistan, Air Strike, Bomb, Civilian Casualties, civilian death toll, civilian deaths, Franz Josef Jung, fuel tankers, Germany, Kunduz, Nato, Taliban. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. ...
  • Blog Source: www.stripes.com
    A German defense spokesman told reporters on Friday that German officials were not aware of any civilians killed in Friday's airstrike. But he added: "We assume almost all killed people were insurgents." NATO and Afghan authorities have started ...
  • Blog Source: www.floppingaces.net
    ISAF/NATO Commander, General Stanley McChrystal, has his hands full these days. Within hours of forwarding a strategic analysis of the situation in Afghanistan – describing it as “…serious, but success is achievable…” – to U.S. Central
Images
 >
 
Videos
 >
 
Reported by farhat96
Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Cell phones Cell phones use report code: @4096797

Most Popular Reports

Related Tweets

  • barbdelollis

    @barbdelollis RT @scoopingthenews: New Twitter record for journalists: @sportsguy33 was re-tweeted 415 times in last 24 hours.

    3 months ago
  • ssstrom

    @ssstrom Brown shoots? RT @pndblog: U.S. Census releases 2008 household income (down), poverty (up) numbers http://bit.ly/NdhMs

    3 months ago
  • HowardKurtz

    @HowardKurtz A gripping account by the NYT reporter who was rescued in Afghanistan, leavened by British understatement. http://tinyurl.com/nfb74r

    3 months ago
  • timesjoanna

    @timesjoanna @mikewhills It's not exhaustive, but here is a list of many of the #timestwitterers http://bit.ly/2GJJgr

    3 months ago
  • klustout

    @klustout "Reckless." Afghan journalists condemn NATO raid that rescued Stephen Farrell & killed Sultan Munadi http://bit.ly/LunFh #cnn

    3 months ago
  • idesk

    @idesk iDeskCNN: rt @akegroup AKE warns of further kidnappings following the release of a British journalist in Afghanistan: http://tiny.cc/akeafghan

    3 months ago
  • markknoller

    @markknoller Obama says his plan will cost $900-billion: "less than we have spent on the Iraq and Afghanistan wars..."

    3 months ago
  • johncabell

    @johncabell @wryandginger it's a little ... foppish. And who says I share?

    3 months ago
  • andersoncooper

    @andersoncooper many family members of #veterans commenting on our live coverage out of Afghanistan this week

    3 months ago
  • SI_JonHeyman

    @SI_JonHeyman @ryanmgeeks yes, you are right about that. his timing was off.

    3 months ago

Related Allvoices Reports

Related People

Contributions

Help and Accounts


Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc 2008-2009. All rights reserved.