The leading source for credible citizen reporting

Report Your News
Take the tour...

Are these Remnants (see pics) of the Gandhi Legacy REALLY Worth $1.8 million??

By: myVox send a private message
Middletown : NY : USA | 9 months ago  
Views: 177
  • Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's humble Leather Slippers
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's humble Leather Slippers
    Posted by: myVox
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's humble Leather Slippers
  • Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Circular Pocket Watch
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Circular Pocket Watch
    Posted by: myVox
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Circular Pocket Watch 
  • Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Trademark Round Glasses
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Trademark Round Glasses
    Posted by: myVox
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Trademark Round Glasses
  • Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Silver Bowl and Humble Plate
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Silver Bowl and Humble Plate
    Posted by: myVox
    Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's Silver Bowl and Humble Plate
  • Return Nation's Father Gandhi Ji Traditional Articals - How Poignant even with the Spelling Error!!
    Return Nation's Father Gandhi Ji Traditional Articals - How Poignant ...
    Posted by: myVox
    Return Nation's Father Gandhi Ji Traditional Articals - How Poignant even ...
  • Gandhi Arifacts on Auction - The Buyer & The Seller!!!!!!
    Gandhi Arifacts on Auction - The Buyer & The Seller!!!!!!
    Posted by: myVox
    Gandhi Arifacts on Auction - The Buyer & The Seller!!!!!!
  • Antiquorum - AntiEthics, shall we Say??
    Antiquorum - AntiEthics, shall we Say??
    Posted by: myVox
    Antiquorum - AntiEthics, shall we Say??
Antiquorum Auction - Gandhi's humble Leather Slippers

A few of the items that once belonged to Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi were auctioned in New York for a whopping $1.8 million. And to note that the items were the very humble Gandhian round glasses, his leather sandals, a pocket watch, a bowl and a plate & a few other personal belongings of Bapu.

Were the items really worth $1.8 million? Why was the Indian Government hell bent upon getting the vestiges of Gandhi's legacy back to India? Will there ever be an end to a man's greed?

As far as my last query goes I am talking James Otis here. The guy now claims he has Gandhi's ashes as also the Mahatma's blood sample. Gearing for round 2 of the auction I guess. ATROTIOUS is the word that comes to my mind!!

Meanwhile, a typical reaction that has come in from "The Gandhi Foundation Executive Committee" to the much publicised and dramatised auction is appended below: “It is rather obscene that items belonging to a man who deliberately led a simple lifestyle are now being sold to the highest bidder in a capitalist system, which Gandhi rejected. The items should rightfully belong in a national museum. It’s a pity that his message is not adopted with the same vigour with which his possessions are being exploited.” - Omar Hayat

I would like to hear all your voices in response to my three queries in the text above, to the statement made by Omar Hayat just prior to this sentence and my basic query in the title of this report.

I hope you will all pour in with your valuable views.

In Anticipation, - myVox

  • Print
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Stumbleupon
News Stories
 
  • News Source: The Economic Times | 9 months ago
    A city NGO has asked industrialist Vijay Mallya, who bought Mahatma Gandhi's personal belongings at a New York auction, to display the items in all state capitals of the country before handing them over to Centre. "The people of our country will get...
  • News Source: Daily News & Analysis | 9 months ago
    An engineer and real estate businessman now living in Montreal, Roy drove here to participate in the auction of Gandhi's belongings and bid passionately till liquor baron Vijay Mallya outbid him. With tears in his eyes, the disappointed 72-year-old...
  • News Source: Tamil Net | 9 months ago
    Liquor baron buys Gandhi memorabilia in US auction [TamilNet, Monday, 09 March 2009, 12:10 GMT] The spectacles, chapels, pocket watch and eating plate along with a bowl, used by Mahatma Gandhi were bought for 92 million Indian rupees by Bangalore...
  • News Source: Times of India | 9 months ago
    Why was it so important to get Gandhi’s possessions back in India?...And now that we have got back all the Gandhi memorabilia, what will we do with it? Revere it and put it on display at all the Gandhi memorials all of us visit so often? Use it as...
  • News Source: Androscoggin News | 9 months ago
    Dear Mrs. Sonia Gandhi, On International Women’s Day, through the Bombay Times that I have been kindly invited to edit, I take the liberty of addressing five questions to you that are on my mind. I am a great admirer of you and your family, Mrs...
  • News Source: Channel NewsAsia | 9 months ago
    India is preparing legislation to prevent more of Mahatma Gandhi's belongings being auctioned off abroad, after a recent sale sparked outrage, the Press Trust of India reported on Sunday. A senior official at the ministry of culture told the news...
Blogs
 >
  • Posted By monina monina | 9 months ago
    Gandhi was a simple man and it is ironic that his belongings are being sold by his government for that amount. A better place for Gandhi's mementos is a museum dedicated solely to him. People need to be reminded of the basic things so we can go back to what is really important.
  • Reply By myVox myVox | 9 months ago
    monina, you've got it wrong. Indian Govt is not selling the erstwhile Gandhi belongings. In fact, it has bought them as a certain James Otis had put those on auction. The concerned items were gifts to some people by the Mahatma. Otis had purportedly bought those 'gifts' earlier from those people and then sold them recently thru' an auction house - Antiquorum - in New York.
  • Posted By clayrung clayrung | 9 months ago
    Isn’t it better to place such things in museums, so everyone can have a look at them. It should be a public property. Giving its ownership to one individual doesn’t really make sense.
  • Posted By myVox myVox | 9 months ago
    monina, you've got it wrong. Indian Govt is not selling the erstwhile Gandhi belongings. In fact, it has bought them as a certain James Otis had put those on auction. The concerned items were gifts to some people by the Mahatma. Otis had purportedly 'bought' those gifts earlier from those people and then sold them recently thru' an auction house - Antiquorum - in New York.
  • Posted By slydog slydog | 9 months ago
    I agree with the statement from the Ghandi Foundation. This is
    an atrocious greed-driven affair.

    As for your 3 points; (1) Let the buyer beware..the items are priceless to some..worthless to others

    (2)I suppose India wants to reclaim some relics from the estate of
    a revered folk Hero from their land.

    (3)Greed is a very human condition..greater people than you or I
    have addressed this question since we first walked upright! I know
    of no answer to the problem except being satisfied with what you have!
  • Posted By myVox myVox | 9 months ago
    Thanks for your observations, slydog. I liked your point "being satisfied with what you have!".
  • Posted By InspectorGadget InspectorGadget | 9 months ago
    Nope, the items are definitely not worth anything near $1.8 million. At the end of the day, glasses are glasses, and a pocket watch is a pocket watch. They are ordinary items, and there is nothing too special about them.
  • Posted By myVox myVox | 9 months ago
    Oh yeah, if only biz tycoons / governments know better, hawks like Otis cannot make a killing!! The guy must be in the seventh heaven now on his (Otis) Elevator trip!!
  • Reported by myVox
    Report Your News Got a similar story?
    Add it to the network!

    Or add related content to this report

    Cell phones Cell phones use report code: @2674419

    Most Popular Reports

    Related People

    Contributions

    Help and Accounts


    Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

    © Allvoices, Inc 2008-2009. All rights reserved.