The leading source for credible citizen reporting

Report Your News
Take the tour...

Baby put in boiling oil actually safe; Rationalists explain

By: pranay send a private message
Hubli : India | 11 months ago  
Views: 1,378
  • Baby Safe in Boiling Oil?
    Baby Safe in Boiling Oil?
    Posted by: pranay
    Mohan Guru Swami dips a baby into "Bubbling" oil while practicing a strange ...
Baby Safe in Boiling Oil?

Rationalists have given an official explanation regarding the incident that I had reported on allvoices around two weeks ago. As it appears on TOI today, the baby that was 'dunked' into boiling oil and 'miraculously' came out alive was actually never in any danger, according to the rationalists who examined the situation.

They offered a scientific explanation. In Hubli, Mohan Guru Swami, the head priest of Lord Ayyapa Temple, boiled 10 kg of oil and dipped a year old baby into the pan for a split second. Professor Narendra Nayak, a post-graduate in medical biochemistry and national president of Federation of Indian Rationalists Association explained that these incidents are due to the oil-bubble effect.

When two viscous liquids of different specific gravities are mixed and slightly heated, the heavier one starts bubbling, creating an articial boiling impression. As bubbles rise to the top and form a froth-like formation along with smoke-like fumes, people mistake that it is boiling, said Prof. Nayak. This according to him is the Leidenfrost effect,in which a liquid, in near contact with a mass significantly hotter than its boiling point, produces an insulating vapour layer which keeps that liquid from boiling rapidly.

In my point of view, the rationalists explanation serves as just a scientific explanation to why the baby survived but it should not mean the couples should go about dipping their infants in a pot of boiling oil. It is good to have faith in people and God, but once they start doing activities that alter your perception of reality and trick you into believing that they have been sent by God, ask you to donate money so that a problem of yours disappears, regardless of any religion, then it is just wrong.

Source: TOI

  • Print
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Stumbleupon

Related Allvoices Contributions

News Stories
 
  • News Source: Time of India | 11 months ago
    That’s the burning question after recent incidents of babies being dunked in boiling water and bubbling oil. While God-fearing people call it a miracle, rationalists give a scientific explanation. In Hubli on Sunday, Mohan Guru Swami, head priest...
Blogs
 >
  • Posted By solitaire solitaire | 11 months ago
    Whoa.. even so, DONT TRY THIS AT HOME, PEOPLE!
  • Reply By pranay pranay | 11 months ago
    exactly!! this is not an excuse to perform this stunt!
  • Posted By Popri Popri | 11 months ago
    Oh my...These people did scare the hell outa me, the first time I read your news report about this baby put in boiling water, I was liek I am gonna throw these people in boiling water and ask them how it feels. ;-)
  • Reply By shackled001 shackled001 | 11 months ago
    hahah good one popri! im sure the Priests or the family had no clue about it. Rationalists may have their views but seems like just the belief in the ritual saved the kid!? im still wondering!

    *i sound like a parent who might end up doing this for sake of belief
  • Reported by pranay
    Report Your News Got a similar story?
    Add it to the network!

    Or add related content to this report

    Cell phones Cell phones use report code: @2182681

    Most Popular Reports

    Contributions

    Help and Accounts


    Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

    © Allvoices, Inc 2008-2009. All rights reserved.