Is there something wrong with being a Muslim in United States?
Local to Global News
 
 Connect 
Sign up now!

Is there something wrong with being a Muslim in United States?

San Francisco : CA : USA | Oct 20, 2008 at 1:36 PM PDT
13 3
Views: 939
 
Is there something wrong with being a Muslim in USA

Obama has consistently denied being a Muslim, whenever the Republican Party has had made claims that “Obama is a Muslim you know”. Obama and his party have always come out and said that he is a Christian and not a Muslim.

General Collin Powell mentioned in his interview with NBC, the right answer should be What if he is? Is there something wrong with being a Muslim in the US?

I am an American Muslim and I am disappointed in Obama for not taking the debate further, why should being a Muslim matter? Instead Obama choose to appease his base by denouncing being a Muslim. Today, in America Muslims are worse off than being black. Being a Muslim is the new black in the US.

General Powell went further in his interview saying, “ Is there something wrong with some seven- year-old Muslim American kid believing that he or she could be president? Yet I have heard senior members of my own party drop the suggestion “He ‘s a Muslim and he might be associated terrorists” This is not the way we should be doing it in America”.

General Powell, I have a seven year old son, who is a Muslim American, he was born in San Francisco on 9/18, who does believes that he can do and be anyone he wants to be when he grows up.

I have lived in three different countries, Pakistan, Australia and US. I choose San Francisco (USA) to have a family and raise kids. The reason is that as I find San Francisco bet open and welcoming to different ethnicity, religion and gender. I hope when my son grows up, America will not focus on a person’s religion, gender or race, but on who the person is and what he or she is capable of. I came to this country, as I strongly believed that America was a place of Meritocracy, It did not matter who you were and were you came from. What mattered were your attitude, you skills and your will to achieve!

Back
1 of 3
Next
Is there something wrong with being a Muslim in the US
Is there something wrong with being a Muslim in the US
Amra Tareen is based in San Francisco, California, United States of America, and is an Anchor for Allvoices.
Report Credibility
 
 
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
 
 
Advertisement
 
Posted By GoGreen GoGreen | over 3 years ago

This is a great report Amra as you've brought up a very important point.  There is nothing wrong with being a Muslim American.  The fact that there is a negative connotation with 'Muslim' in the U.S. is extremely unfortunate.  What message does this send young Muslim-Americans whose families have embraced and shown allegiance to America?


It is shameful that the Republicans used the topic of being Muslim as part of their attack campaign against Obama because what religion a candidate/person is shouldn't matter.  Colin Powell is right; so what if he is?  The Republicans are wrongfully playing off of American fear of Muslims.  Obama rightfully corrected the attacks by stating his actual religion, however he should have stated that there is nothing wrong with being a Muslim-American.  I like Obama considerably, but it showed lack of thoughtfulness and weakness on his part especially since he has African-American heritage (i.e. he's 1/2 white and 1/2 African-American) and should be more sensitive to discrimination.  After the attacks from the McCain campaign, the Obama campaign was clearly afraid of having any Muslim association (they gave into to political fear).  This all showed the dirty and frustrating side of politics in this country.
 
Americans (and all people) must remind themselves how dangerous it is to generalize.  Americans are hyper-sensitive about Muslims right now, but they must realize the majority of Muslims are wonderful people.  Even though the Muslim extremists are very high-profile right now and are tarnishing the image of Islam, Americans should not associate all Muslims with extremists/terrorists.  Should we stay on alert for suspicious or possible terrorist behavior in any individual (w/ any religious background)?  Yes.  Should we give into paranoia and make assumptions and generalizations about people with a specific faith?  Absolutely not.

Posted By call_kathy call_kathy | over 3 years ago

I agree with what you have written here, Amra. It shouldn't matter in today's world what you believe or if you believe. Traditional religion really has no place in today's politics.


I think it is very sad that so much of the country believes that it is a problem for anyone to believe differently from them. I don't think any of us have the answer. I think instead, we all have a lot of questions.


In my opinion, it might do the US good to have a president who is not Christian. It might be possible then for us to leave the differences in our belief sets behind us once and for all and instead concentrate on what works for us as a country.

Posted By pastery pastery | over 3 years ago

The irony of all this is really that the US never have been truly equal under the eyes of the law. It is the game of images. Sure the Constitution states that everyone should be equal under the eyes of the law, but can someone honestly claim that to be true? The US is only a place of Meritocracy on paper, but worse than other countries in the sense that many (especially American) still believe it is really true for the US. The world including the US still is a place where who you are, what you believe in, how you look and so forth matter. Quite sad to be honest. Should it be that way? Definitely not, but hiding from this reality will not solve anything. We should work as a global society on changing it.

Reply By amra1 Amra Tareen | over 3 years ago

Pastery, I agree with you, I am trying to do my part via allvoices, I really want to make a global impact!  and create a diverse and global community on allvoices

Reply By pastery pastery | over 3 years ago

The challenge is to as a company be open and diverse in itself, as well as really listen to the community. I have seen so many community sites fail because they try to stick down their own beliefs, preconceptions and opinions down the throat of their community. Inviting a community is “simple”, yet one of the most challenging things to attempt. It is about realizing that what you as a community site think is completely non-important. You have to genuinely speak, think and breath community in all your interaction and realize that communities are not built, they are invited. It is not about design. It is not about functionality. It is about people. People come if they feel connected and invited. You have to realize that you are but only a part of the community.

Advertisement
 

News Stories

 
  • Powell's nod gives Obama security credentials

    Kuwait Times
    October 21, 2008 Former US secretary of state Colin Powell, the nationally respected military leader who served in the first Republican administration of President George W Bush, turned the tables on his own party Sunday by endorsing Democratic...
  • Endorsement aside, Powell delivered a powerful message

    The San Antonio Express-News
    It may have been hard to tell in the hyperpolitical atmosphere of an American presidential race, but Colin Powell's most powerful words Sunday had nothing to do with endorsing Barack Obama...Powell, in a cool, measured eloquence befitting a retired...
  • Powell's Endorsement an Indictment of GOP

    Truthout
    Specialist Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan and this photo were highlighted by Powell's rebuke of racism in GOP politics. (Photo: Platon / The New Yorker)     Gen. Colin Powell's endorsement of Barack Obama on Sunday was more than just a nod of approval.
  • Detroit Free Press: Time for us vs. them to be just us

    Androscoggin News
    The most important thing that former Secretary of State Colin Powell pointed out during his weekend endorsement of Sen. Barack Obama for president was not about Obama or Sen. John McCain. It was about the sentiment that has crept into the...
  • Colin Powell’s, “So What?” Misses the Point

    Canadian Free Press
    Had John McCain been in attendance during such a pastoral tirade, he would almost certainly have left the premises immediately and denounced the pastor’s hateful anti-American message.   Lest we allow political correctness to gloss over truth,...
  • Powell Said What Obama Couldn’t

    Truthdig
    Powell told Tom Brokaw that he still believes that war was the right course of action, based on what he and other officials knew—or thought they knew—at the time...And he said he still opposes a “deadline” for withdrawing U.S. troops, though he added...

Blogs

 >
  • The Facts Speak for Themselves

    jamartell.blogspot.com
    On 9/28/2001, he says, "I have already said that I am not involved in the September 11 attacks in the United States. As a Muslim, I try my best to avoid telling a lie. I had no knowledge of these attacks, nor do I consider the killing ...
  • Notes about America: An Expat Perspective

    lifeinthetropics.wordpress.com
    Of course, as Colin Powell said recently, if he was a Muslim what difference would it make. Despite Palin’s fantasy that America is a Christian nation, the fact is that it isn’t and that’s one of the great things about America - the ...
  • THE WORLD today!

    1read.wordpress.com
    The US industrial production dropped 2,8% in September, the largest decline since 1974 and retail sales slowed down 1,2% the same month, the worst decline in three years, while global car sales fell 6% in the third quarter. ...
  • McCAIN AND OBAMA - class enemies of the workers

    gangbox.wordpress.com
    Taking their cue from Challenge, PL supporters have gone the next logical step, literally registering voters for Obama. Without comment, Challenge (4 October) printed a letter signed by one “Red Registrar” who boasts: “I helped out at a ...
  • Update no.357

    heartlandupdate.blogspot.com
    I listened to the endorsement of Senator Obama by former Secretary of State General Colin Luther Powell, USA (Ret.) – a very logical, balanced, thoughtful statement. I hope he is correct about Senator Obama – the junior senator from ...
  • DO NOT SELL OUT YOUR GD, YOUR FAMILY, YOUR COUNTRY, YOUR ...

    actionsbyt.blogspot.com
    "Over the past month I have been on combat patrol from coast to coast for the truth and for the United States Constitution," says Andy. "I have not the slightest link to John McCain. I am connected to the Constitution and nothing else. ...

Images

 >
 

Videos

 >
 

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

 
Tap_logo_330_103

Sitemap


Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc 2008-2012. All rights reserved.