Joy as gay bishops approved by Church of England (as long as they don't have sex)

Joy as gay bishops approved by Church of England (as long as they don't have sex)

London : United Kingdom | Jan 04, 2013 at 5:11 PM PST
Views: Pending
The Anglican communion has witnessed a decade of turmoil, including over the issue of openly gay bishops

Gay Christians are celebrating as the Church of England has announced that it has dropped its ban on gay bishops. As many rejoice, others fear the move will lead to huge divisions within the Church of England membership.

The caveat is that while allowing gay clergy in civil partnerships to become bishops, they can only become so if they pledge that their gay relationships are celibate.

Evangelical Anglicans around the world have already stated that they will fight the move even if it means that they will split from the formal Church of England. Anglicans in the UK have said that they would rather import a heterosexual bishop from overseas than serve under a gay bishop.

Invigilator believes, along with many others, that the "celibate" pledge is something that it is impossible for the church to police and should be consigned to the dustbin. It's also a disappointment that lesbians will not be allowed to become bishops. In fact, no women, straight or gay, will be allowed to become bishops.

The decision was made by the Church of England before Christmas but has only now been announced. It was probably thought too explosive an issue to announce in the lead up to Christmas. Instead the church announced its decision to allow gay bishops on Friday in the Church Times newspaper.

In November, the General Synod of the Church of England rejected formal proposals to allow women to become bishops, and church acceptance of gay bishops has taken many by surprise.

The allowing of gay bishops in the Church of England comes at a time when the British government has made it illegal for gay couples to be married in a Church of England or Church of Wales church.

Gay clergy can now become bishops as long as they repent any former active homosexual acts and pledge to remain celibate in the future even if they are in a legal partnership with another man.

The acceptance of gay clergy into the role of bishops reminds us of the case of the gay cleric, Jeffrey John, who was nominated for the post of Bishop of Reading in 2003. Traditionalist Christians waged a vicious war of words against him and forced him to withdraw from the post after initially accepting it.

One might imagine that a few years on attitudes in the church would have changed. They have in that the Church of England authorities will now allow gay bishops, but out in the real world of Christian evangelicals, attitudes might even have hardened against the idea of gay and women bishops.

An example of such bigotry is the Rev. Rod Thomas, chairman of the evangelical group Reform, who said: “It would be far better for the Church just to be clear that if you are in a civil partnership then being a leader in a church is not appropriate for you because the Church has to uphold its moral teaching on marriage. If the Church doesn’t uphold that then it’s difficult to know what the Church is in business to do.”

The Scotsman quotes a more enlightened clergyman, the Rt Rev. Graham James, Bishop of Norwich, speaking on behalf of the House of Bishops, saying that it would be “unjust” to exclude anyone for consideration for the role of bishop who was “seeking to live fully in conformity with the Church’s teaching on sexual ethics or other areas of personal life and discipline. All candidates for the episcopate undergo a searching examination of personal and family circumstances, given the level of public scrutiny associated with being a bishop in the Church of England.”

Whise welcoming the Church of England's move to now allow gay bishops, human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell said: “The restriction that they can be only appointed if they remain celibate is continued discrimination.The Church should welcome love, fidelity and commitment, regardless of whether its bishops are heterosexual or homosexual.”

Sources and more on this story:


The Independent

The Scotsman

1 of 2
Williams indicated that he could not endorse bishops in active gay relationships
Williams indicated that he could not endorse bishops in active gay relationships
INVIGILATOR is based in Nottingham, England, United Kingdom, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Church Of England Says Gay Men Can Be Bishops

      Sky News
    Gay clergy will be allowed to become bishops if they are in civil partnerships and promise to be celibate, the Church of England has announced. The Bishop of Norwich, the Rt Revd Graham James, said it would be "unjust" to stop homosexual clergy...
  • Gay bishops allowed – but they can't have sex

      The Independent
    Suggested Topics The Church of England reopened the most divisive issue in Anglicanism tonight by unexpectedly announcing that openly gay men could become bishops, providing they are celibate. The timing of the decision took both supporters and...
  • Church of England to allow gay bishops

      News 24
    The Church of England has dropped its opposition to gay clergymen in civil partnerships becoming bishops, it confirmed on Friday. The announcement by the church's House of Bishops would allow a homosexual clergyman in a civil partnership to become a...
  • Church drops gay bishop opposition

    The Church has already agreed to allow people in civil partnerships to become clergy The Church of England has dropped its prohibition on gay clergy becoming bishops. The announcement, from the Church's House of Bishops, would allow clergy in civil...
  • Church of England drops opposition to gay clergy in civil partnerships ...

      The Independent
    Suggested Topics The Church of England has dropped its ban on gay clergy in civil partnerships becoming bishops. An announcement made from the Church's House of Bishops, said the CofE would allow gay clergy to become bishops providing they remain...
  • Church of England to allow gay bishops

      United Press International
    Gay men in civil partnerships who agree to be celibate may become bishops, the Church of England says. The decision, reported Friday, was made by the House of Bishops at a meeting in December, The Guardian said. The bishops said they would take no...



More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.