Houston Texans linebacker fined $30,000 for dirty hit

Houston Texans linebacker fined $30,000 for dirty hit

Chicago : IL : USA | Nov 15, 2012 at 2:29 PM PST
Views: Pending
Vicious hit results in $30,000 fine for Houston linebacker

The National Football League has fined Houston Texans linebacker Tim Dobbins for a helmet-to-helmet blow that inficted a concussion on Chicago Bears’ quarterback Jay Cutler.

Two other quarterbacks, Michael Vick of the Philadelphia Eagles and Alex Smith of the San Francisco 49ers, suffered concussions the same day.

Dobbins was not suspended for his hit, which YouTube videos showed was launched after Cutler had stopped running forward so he could pass without crossing the scrimmage line.

He failed and was penalized for passing beyond the line of scrimmage, and so did Dobbins, who was penalized, but not ejected. Cutler played a few more downs before the half ended. He didn’t return.

“I’m definitely disappointed. I didn’t know if he was going to run the ball or he was going to pass the ball. I felt like he was past the line and I just went and tried to get a clean hit on him. It didn’t work out, I guess,” he told Bloomberg.

In fact, the videos show Cutler had already passed the ball when Dobbin crushed him.

The NFL is facing a lawsuit from players over permitting hits that would be more appropriate in a gladiator arena.

The league is defending the way it handles such hits by saying players, just like soldiers, hide the extent of their injuries. They don’t want to pulled from important games, letting down their teammates, and possibly losing their jobs.

Sporting News said 56 percent of the players it polled would hide their injuries if possible.

This weekend will be a big test. Will Cutler, Smith and Vick play? If they do they could risk “second-impact syndrome,” which means a player could die if the brain swelling has not gone down enough.

And Dobbin's coach defended him on the Ultimate Texans Website: “When did he get a concussion?” Wade Phillips said. “You can’t say he got it (on Dobbins’ blow) for sure. When (the quarterback) is throwing the ball, you have to be careful. You can’t determine if he’s one yard or two yards across the line of scrimmage (Cutler was ruled to have crossed the line, which negated Dobbins’ roughness penalty). I’m not saying the guy shouldn’t be fined. I’m just saying I don’t understand the fine system." http://blog.chron.com/ultimatetexans/2012/11/texans%E2%80%99-phillips-says-nfl-fines-biased-against-defenders/


NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell sounded like Mitt Romney when he told an audience at Harvard on Thursday that the sport will evolve and get safer. How? He didn’t say how.

The League needs to ask itself this question: do viewers pay to watch games to see the Cutlers, Elways, Mannings, Montanas, Favres, or to see some player whose goal is to knock the top attractions from the game, bounty or not?

It may be time to look at helmets. Have they become weapons. They don’t use them in rugby.

It seems only a matter of time until a hit like the one dealt Cutler will result in benches emptying and a fight ensuing, such as already occurs in the National Hockey League.

1 of 2
The NFL has fined veteran linebacker Tim Dobbins of the Houston Texans for a vicious helmet-to-helmet hit of Bears quarterback Jay Cutler. It is not known whether Cutler will be able to play this weekend against the 49ers.
Robert Weller is based in Denver, Colorado, United States of America, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • NFL commissioner says sport will evolve, get safer

      Turks and Caicos Free Press
    Professional football can evolve into a safer game without losing the physical play or, some would say, violence that has made it so popular, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell said in a speech on player safety at the Harvard School of Public Health on...
  • Bears, Cutler suffer while NFL fiddles

      The Daily Herald
    If this concussion discussion is at times enough to give you a headache, youre not alone. In the wake of Jay Cutler, Alex Smith and Mike Vick all going down on the same Sunday, there was much talk last week, and most of it nonsensical. First, the...
  • Bears' Jay Cutler ruled out for 49ers game

      Contra Costa Times
    The Chicago Bears say quarterback Jay Cutler will miss Monday's game against the 49ers at Candlestick Park because of a concussion. Jason Campbell, the former Raiders quarterback, is expected to start in his place. Cutler's status was in question...
  • Roger Goodell, N.F.L. Commissioner, Speaks on Concussions

      The New York Times
    Goodell, who has been criticized for not doing enough to reduce concussions and other head injuries, spoke in a room packed with students and professors at the Harvard School of Public Health. Changing the culture in a way that reduces the injury...
  • Nick Tavares: NFL injuries keep piling up

      Acushnet Community News
    Today is Sunday, at that means, of course, that it's time for football...The same way I get geared up for Sunday Night Baseball in the summer (unless it's another five-hour Red Sox/Yankees snooze fest), NBC's Sunday night game is typically a welcome...
  • Extra Points: Examining the NFL's concussion crisis

      The Bellingham Herald
    Three significant starting quarterbacks went down with concussions, Philadelphia' Michael Vick, the 49ers' Alex Smith and Chicago's Jay Cutler. The Eagles lost Vick early in the second quarter of their latest loss to Dallas, while the mighty 49ers...



More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.