Canadian politics: Abortion motion on when life begins defeated

Canadian politics: Abortion motion on when life begins defeated

Ottawa : Canada | Sep 27, 2012 at 7:04 AM PDT
Views: Pending
Canada AM - Supreme Court Divorce Case

Despite fears that the Canadian Conservative government was attempting to reopen the abortion issue, which was settled by the Supreme Court while Brian Mulroney was in power in 1988, the Canadian Parliament handily defeated the motion 203-91. The 91 votes in favour of the motion were registered by conservative Members of Parliament.

The Conservative government in Canada was accused of wanting to reopen the debate in order to undermine Canada's liberal abortion law. Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who voted against the motion, had said all along that he had no interest in reopening the debate.

One of the senior federal cabinet ministers, Immigration Minister Jason Kenney supported the motion and was slammed by the New Democratic Party's Nikki Ashton. She wondered why the minister was standing agains the government wishes.

“It comes as a surprise in a sense that we know that Mr. Kenney is very close to the Prime Minister. The question here is why he’s choosing to stand up against the government’s wishes.”

Ms Ashton and fellow NDP MP Francois Boivin also suggested that the motion should have been shut down and not come up for a vote.

Parliamentary rules, however, direct that a private members motion is only non-votable, if it does not come under federal jurisdiction. Abortion clearly does.

One of the major pro-life groups in Canada, the Campaign Life Coalition, said it was not deterre by the vote. In a tweet to its followers it said, “No matter, this motion succeeded in creating a necessary debate.”

Conservative Member of Parliament, Stephen Woodworth, who introduce the motion, acknowledged the defeat, but vowed to fight on against the denial of the worth and dignity of every human being.

“I will be there to encourage and to speak out in defence of the Canadian values championed by Motion 312” Woodworth said. “If possible, I’ll travel the country to talk about the very, very grave importance of enshrining in Canadian law the equal worth and dignity of every human being.”

The Supreme Court ruled that criminalizing abortion was unconstitutional in 1988.

R. v. Morgentaler was a decision of the Supreme Court of Canada which held that the abortion provision in the Criminal Code of Canada was unconstitutional, as it violated a woman's right under section 7 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms to security of person. Since this ruling, there have been no criminal laws regulating abortion in Canada. Wikepedia

Opinion: This issue has been discussed to death since the Supreme Court ruling. While society has moved on since the ruling almost a quarter century ago, it seems some can't let sleeping dogs lie. It is truly time to move on. Rona Ambrose, who is the Minister for the Status of Women, voted for the motion as did my own Member of Parliament, Brian Storseth.

While it may be a vote of conscience for the MP, there has never been a query, to my knowledge, of the constituency on how the elecrtorate feels about the issue. MPs should not assume that we support motions of this nature without first inquiring.

Kudos to Prime Minister Harper for not falling into a trap on this motion. He kept his word on this issue.

How they voted: (Huffington Post)

1 of 26
Stephen Harper
Stephen Harper voted against the private member's motion 312, which wanted to study when life begins.
Karl Gotthardt is based in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Controversial abortion motion defeated

      Delhi News-Record
    A majority of MPs rejected a motion put forward by a Tory backbencher calling for review of "when life begins," but eight cabinet ministers supported it, including the government's status of women minister. House leader Peter Van Loan, International...
  • MPs to debate motion to examine when human life begins
    Members of Parliament vote today on a controversial motion that would reopen the abortion debate. Conservative MP Stephen Woodworth insists his private member's bill is not about criminalizing abortion. He says it's only about getting scientific and...
  • Tory MPs divided as fetal-rights motion defeated in Commons
    Prime Minister Stephen Harper's Conservative MPs have been left seriously divided over the issue of abortion after a controversial motion was defeated in the House of Commons on Wednesday evening...But in a surprise development, the vote revealed the...
  • Outrage at Ambrose after 'when life begins' vote

      Delhi News-Record
    Status of Women Minister Rona Ambrose has not explained her motivation for endorsing a controversial motion calling for a review of "when life begins", despite outrage from critics. Ambrose has come under fire from some women's groups and opposition...
  • Heading into vote, Conservatives divided on motion to study when human life ...

      The Globe and Mail
    Story Conservative MP and pro-life supporter Stephen Woodworth takes part in the March For Life rally on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, May 10, 2012. Woodworth is pushing for legislation to have fetuses declared persons The Canadian Press...
  • The preposterous politics of female feticide

      The Globe & Mail
    Story Immigration Minister Jason Kenney, left, and Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz vote on Motion 312 in the House of Commons on Wednesday Sept. 26, 2012. The Globe and Mail Editorial cartoons: September, 2012 First, most people had expected a far...



More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.