Military investigation: Violence and deaths over Quran burnings could have been avoided
Linkedin

Military investigation: Violence and deaths over Quran burnings could have been avoided

Kabul : Afghanistan | Aug 28, 2012 at 8:52 AM PDT
XX XX
Views: Pending
 
RT - Obama Continues Torture at 'Secret Prisons'

A U.S. military investigative report released on Monday found that U.S. troops tried to burn 500 copies of the Quran despite warnings by Afghan officials.

The incident ocurred at Bagram Airbase on February 22nd 2011 at Bagram Airbase in Afghanistan, when troops burned copies of the Quran from the library of the airbase's detention facility.

The incident resulted in protests with violence resulting in 41 deaths and 270 injuries. The incident is also thought to be responsible for attacks by Afghan soldiers and police on NATO troops.

Among the 1652 books removed from the library were 48 copies of the Quran. The books were boxed for storage, but later send to an incinerator, according to the US military mistakenly, to be burned. Afghan garbage collectors found the charred books and informed an Afghan National Army commander.

The books were apparently removed from the library since the US military thought they were being used to pass information by the inmates.

Criminal charges were never filed against the six soldiers involved, despite demands that the soldiers be tried on Afghanistan. The military said that lesser disciplinary action was taken since the incident was unintentional. What that action was has not been disclosed.

The investigation showed a weakness in the training of US troops. There was a lack of awareness of Afghan culture and awareness. According to the report the troops only received about an hours worth of training in the form of a powerpoint presentation. Obviously that is not sufficient.

Prior to deploying to Bosnia this author spend time on a two week course, which included cultural awareness and religious training. This training, although not the end all, be all, is beneficial.

With more than ten years in country by the time these troops deployed there should have been a myriad information available to better prepare these troops. Some of the blame can be placed squarely with the US military.

During 2011 there were several events, including six Marines urinating on dead bodies, that contravened regulations. Those Marines only got a slap in the wrist as well.

Army Brigadier General Brian G. Watson said in the report that the found “malicious intent to disrespect the Qurann or defame the faith of Islam."

“Ultimately, this tragic incident resulted from a lack of cross-talk between leaders and commands, a lack of senior leader involvement and distrust among our US Service Members and our partners,” he said.

Distrust is still a major issue among US troops and the Afghan Security Forces. Recent killings at the hands of Afghan soldiers or police keep re-emphasizing that point.

Afghanistan is turning into a hell hole and not providing troops with cultural awareness training doesn't help.

1 of 1
Bagram Airbase Afghanistan
Bagram Airbase Afghanistan (K.Gotthardt private photo)
Karl Gotthardt is based in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, and is an Anchor for Allvoices.
Report Credibility
 
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
 
 
Advertisement
 
Posted By NinaRai Nina Rai | 9 months ago
How could the US troops be so stupid
to burn something which is obviously
'sacred' for the Muslims. Its like
an open invitation to bloodshed and
violence. Rated^
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | 9 months ago
Lack of knowledge or ignorance of other cultures. That's the only way to describe it.
Posted By DavaCastillo Dava Castillo | 9 months ago
Thanks for the report Karl.

I have to ask why any books would be sent to an incinerator in the first place. When I get rid of books, I donate them to the library--I don't burn them.
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | 9 months ago
I guess it depends on the condition of the books. The problem here apparently was lack of cultural awareness and people refusing to listen to their advisers.
Posted By Anyvoice Anyvoice | 9 months ago
Karl,

You are so right about the military's failure to prepare the soldiers. G.W.'s biggest failure was his adviser's failure to plan for actions to take after the invasion.

With this "culturally sensitive" president there is really no excuse. But then the US military has been trying their best to keep Christianity from the camps, this could mean they just wanted to be fair to all religions. (you know I really don't mean that)
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | 9 months ago
Anyvoice,

Thanks for commenting. The US government and particularly the State Department, has great information, including cultural nuisances from countries around the world. There is no reason for soldiers not being trained in this, regardless of who the President is. It's just plain old common sense.
Posted By NinaRai Nina Rai | 9 months ago
Agree with you Karl..its just
plain old common sense.
Posted By atifji75 atifji75 | 9 months ago
Nice Presentation. Thanks a lot. Rated Up
Advertisement
 

News Stories

 
  • US punishes 6 soldiers for burning the Quran

    The Hindustan Times
    The US will hand over administrative punishment to its six soldiers for their role in desecration of Holy Quran in Afghanistan early this year, an incident that had caused wide-spread protests and riots in the country and forced President Barack...
  • Pentagon finds soldiers who burned Korans ignored Afghan warnings

    Los Angeles Times
    A Pentagon investigation into the burning of Korans at a U.S.-run prison in Afghanistan in February found that American soldiers ignored warnings from an Afghan officer and an interpreter and incinerated dozens of Islamic holy texts in a pit,...
  • U.S. Military Disciplines 9 in Koran Burning and Marine Video

    Newyork Times
    Army officials said that four Army officers and two enlisted soldiers received letters of reprimand for sending boxes of Korans from a prison library to a burn pit at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan. Although an Army investigation that was made public...
  • U.S. troops face punishment over Koran burning, urination video

    Reuters
    News Analysis & Opinion Related Topics Afghan men shout anti-U.S slogans during a protest in Kabul February 23, 2012. The U.S. military is expected to announce disciplinary action on Monday in response to two incidents that provoked outrage in...
  • Soldiers, Marines punished for misconduct

    AP Online
    The Defense Department has given administrative punishments to six Army soldiers for burning Qurans at a U.S. base in Afghanistan, and to three Marines for urinating on the corpses of Taliban insurgents. There were no criminal charges.
  • Military disciplines 9 service members in connection with Afghan incidents

    Washington Post
    After an investigation and disciplinary proceedings that lasted six months, the Army announced Monday that it had punished six soldiers for burning the Koran and other religious tracts while disposing of trash at Bagram Air Base. The Army concluded...

Blogs

 >
  • US Military Disciplines 9 in Koran Burning and Marine Video - Yes

    jbk-current-events.blogspot.com
    Army officials said that four Army officers and two enlisted soldiers received letters of reprimand for sending boxes of Korans from a prison library to a burn pit at Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan. Although an Army investigation that was made ...
  • Soldiers Punished For Misconduct, Mistakenly Burning Qurans ...

    washington.cbslocal.com
    Six Army soldiers and three Marines escaped criminal charges, but received administrative punishments for their involvement in two incidents of misconduct in Afghanistan that roiled relations with Afghans, U.S. military officials said Monday. ... The
  • No charges in Quran burning, video: US military | karachireports

    karachireports.wordpress.com
    The Quran burning triggered Afghan riots and retribution killings, including two U.S. troops who were shot by an Afghan soldier and two U.S. military advisers who were gunned down at their desks at the Interior Ministry. The exact punishments were
  • Taliban rockets hit General Dempsey's plane - Threat Matrix

    www.longwarjournal.org
    Rockets launched by Taliban fighters damaged the airplane used by General Martin Dempsey, the US Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, while it was parked on the runway at Bagram Air Base in Parwan province. Dempsey was in Afghanistan to discuss the
  • Is The US Really Going To Withdraw From Afghanistan? - Stop NATO

    rickrozoff.wordpress.com
    The big ones, like the Shindand air base in Herat province (in close vicinity to Iran) or the Kandahar and Bagram air bases remain basically untouched. And there is every reason to believe that the highly publicized pullout does not concern ...

Images

 >
 

More From Allvoices

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

 
Tap_logo_330_110_event
 


Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc 2008-2013. All rights reserved.