Romney muddles facts on his Medicare plan

Romney muddles facts on his Medicare plan

The Villages : FL : USA | Aug 18, 2012 at 8:37 PM PDT
Views: Pending
Rachel Maddow Kills the Romney/Ryan Medicare Lie Dead In its Tracks

Mitt Romney is sending out his message on Medicare reform to voters. The problem is, it's not accurate.

In a podcast Saturday on the Romney campaign website, the 2012 presidential hopeful told Americans that Obamacare had taken $716 billion from the Medicare fund to finance “his takeover of the health care system.”

In truth, the Obama cuts to the Medicare budget are aimed at reducing provider fraud, waste, and abuse. Nothing in Obamacare scales back benefits for seniors. Obamacare actually adds benefits like preventive screenings at no charge to the patient.

Romney also resurrected the scare tactic of death panels, which was untrue when Sarah Palin used that line of attack, and equally true with Romney's use of it.

Romney accused Obama of denying elderly Americans "the care they've worked for their entire lives, all because President Obama trusts bureaucrats more than he trusts seniors and their doctors," a line repeated in a new Romney-Ryan campaign ad.

However, a Romney administration repeal of Obamacare would actually cut benefits to seniors right away, not 10 years from now, by eliminating the free health screenings covered in Obamacare, along with some prescription drug benefits.

Neither Romney nor Obama deny that their plans for Medicare are very different.

Obama wants to keep the current, government-administered Medicare program and focus cost reduction efforts on controlling waste and abuse from health care providers. The Romney-Ryan plan phases out government involvement in Medicare guarantees and puts seniors in the hands of private insurance companies. A voucher system, Romney calls "premium support," is like a co-pay from the government, to help offset the cost of health insurance premiums for seniors. Vouchers would be paid directly to one of the insurance companies on a list of approved insurers.

The Economic Policy Journal explains in simple terms how the Romney-Ryan Medicare overhaul would work. "For Americans currently under 55, his plan will give them a health insurance voucher as high as $8,000 per year. Government will get to decide what insurance companies are eligible to accept the vouchers. Ryan says all the major health insurers will be approved and accept the vouchers. Guess what that means?"

Limiting seniors to a list of approved insurance companies leaves the door wide open to corruption and price-fixing on the part of insurance companies. Much like a kick-back, which is currently illegal, health insurance companies could exchange the promise of campaign donations for a spot on the list of approved government provider companies.

What the Romney campaign has also failed to acknowledge is what happens when the voucher system kicks in? Will parents be expected to help their children financially if the vouchers are not enough to buy health insurance?

What may sound good to some voters on the campaign trail and in TV commercials does not necessarily reflect the truth. This is a hotly contested presidential race and both sides may be tempted to try to woo voters with false and misleading information.

If the details of Medicare reform make your head spin, there is an easier way to syphon through the rhetoric. For the most part, Democrats, who created Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security, are more likely to work harder at keeping the programs solvent and intact.

Republicans, on the other hand, have historically opposed entitlement programs. They have made numerous attempts to dismantle and/or privatize Social Security, Medicaid and Medicare in the past, and are not ashamed to admit that getting rid of the programs completely is their ultimate goal.

"It only took two hours after the Paul Ryan vice presidential announcement for Republican congressional candidates to get their talking points on how to spin the Ryan budget and Medicare attacks," according to Politico.

Republicans were advised not to use the words, "entitlement reform," "privatization," or "every option is on the table."

Instead, the National Republican Congressional Committee said in an email memo reported in Politico, to use the words "strengthen, secure, save, preserve, and protect.”

Whether the words are true appears to be irrelevant. In an election year, no one who expects to win would dare tell seniors that they intend to take away their Medicare.

If you like to write about U.S. politics and Campaign 2012, enter "The American Pundit" competition. Allvoices is awarding four $250 prizes each month between now and November. These monthly winners earn eligibility for the $5,000 grand prize, to be awarded after the November election.


Romney-Ryan budget: Throw grandma off a cliff

Current seniors face immediate health care cuts under Romney-Ryan plan

Iowa crowd heckles Paul Ryan over Medicare cuts

1 of 2
Romney Medicare message muddles facts
itobin53 is based in Tampa, Florida, United States of America, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • New Romney ad accuses Obama of 'raiding' Medicare

      The Hill
    Obama is raiding $716 billion from Medicare, changing the program forever. Raising taxes on families making less than $120,000," says the narrator in the ad. The ad goes on to tout the "Romney-Ryan" plan, saying that it will restore and protect...
  • Will Obama or Romney save Medicare? And who's telling the truth?

      Kevin M.D. Medical Blog
    The media reports have to be in the thousands, all trying to make sense of the furious debate between Obama and Romney over Medicare. As someone who has studied this issue for more than 20 years, it has also been more than exasperating for me to...
  • What Does Circumcision Have to do With our Nation's Health Care Costs?

      The GoHealth Coverage Corner
    August 16, 2012 At GoHealth, we strive to empower consumers with all the information they need to make an informed decision about which health insurance plan is right for them. As part of this ongoing effort, take a look at these 8 Things to Know...
  • Romney and Obama Campaigns Seize Role of Medicare Defender

      The New York Times
    Mr. Ryan, who has proposed a controversial voucher program for Medicare, accused Mr. Obama of being the bigger threat because of savings wrung from the growth of spending in the program contained in the president's health care overhaul of 2010. He...
  • Medicare: Schoolyard rules apply

      Tulsa World
    Taking command of the French ninth army in 1914 as it retreated before the Germans, Marshal Ferdinand Foch uttered his immortal words: "Hard pressed on my right...The best Mitt Romney ad of the campaign is the current spot on President Barack Obama's...
  • Costs Seen in Romney's Medicare Savings Plan

      The New York Times
    The 2010 health care law cut Medicare reimbursements to hospitals and insurers, not benefits for older Americans, by that amount over the coming decade. But repealing the savings, policy analysts say, would hasten the insolvency of Medicare by eight...



More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.