The US Supreme Court Verdict on the PPACA Ignites 2012 Presidential Campaign

The US Supreme Court Verdict on the PPACA Ignites 2012 Presidential Campaign

Ilion : NY : USA | Jul 12, 2012 at 10:10 AM PDT
Views: Pending
Anonymous: System Failure

Twenty-eight states, numerous organizations, and a number of private citizens filed actions in federal court challenging the consititutionality of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act ( PPACA).But on June 28, 2012,the Supreme Court upheld the majority of the law. Health care reform was a major topic of discussion also during the 2008 Presidential elections in the USA New York, Senator Hillary Clinton and the eventual nominee, Illinois Senator Barack Obama that time proposed a plan to cover the approximately 45 million Americans estimated to be without health insurance at some point during each year. Clinton's plan was to require all Americans to obtain coverage .He stressed on an individual health insurance.On the other hand Obama was to provide a subsidy but not create a direct requirement. People earning less than four times the poverty line ($92.200 per year for a family of four) will receive tax credits to subsidize their purchase of insurance. Medicaid eligibility is expanded to include those earning up to 133% of the poverty line.The two chambers of Congress had had detailed discussion for one year on the Act till it was signed into law by Obama on March 23, 2010. It is now referred to as Obamacare.According to many of Obama’s opponents in the election , healthcare law is bad policy for patients, doctors, healthcare providers, and administrators, small business and the middle class.The law will introduce 21 law taxes and it will affect badly the middle classes. Never before there was so much apprehension of tax increase on the middle class. The implementation of the law will make many jobless and there will be fewer number of new employees.Average New York senior will have to spend over $700 for prescription drugs if the PPACA is not repealed. The proposal of the Democrats is that the Republican should cooperate with them for improving the PPACA. Some Republicans at the time of passing the PPACA joined the Democratic colleagues, but strangely enough the House Republicans have voted to repeal the PPACA. The Supreme Court verdict will dampen the spirit of the Republican who voted 33rd time . For the Democrats the move to repeal the Act is nothing more than political show off. Thus the Election campaign in the USA reaches its peak over the PPACA issue in the context of the recent verdict of the Supreme Court against the repeal.

It is undeniable that the PPCA is not very much popular and the Americans resent the way the law was passed. It violates the democratic spirit of America. It is draconian. The Demorcrats however, argue that the efforts to repeal the law will distract the attention of the people from many important issues , like the economy and job creation. According to the Republicans ,the consequences of the Supreme Court verdict are so significant and so serious to the economy, to jobs and to the middle class. 239 Republicans and five Democrats supported the “Repeal of Obamacare Act” which has many problems as it places a dozen new tax increases on middle class Americans. It places new mandates on small businesses and levies penalties which burden Upstate businesses and drain capital from growth. Additionally, the law has not lowered health care premiums.

However, the Republicans should not forget that they themselves had introduced similar reform proposals in the 1990s. In 1993 Senator John Chafee introduced the Health Equity and Access Reform Today Act which contained a "Universal Coverage" requirement with a penalty for non-compliance. In 1994 the Consumer Choice Health Security Act was also introduced by Don Nicles and the Act also contained an individual mandate with a penalty provision.So the Supreme Court verdict will not bring a majority of people against the Democrats. The Republicans are not in a position to challenge the Supreme Court verdict and get the mandate of the people so easily. They have not yet been able to show any better alternative. American people are still not sure of the consequences in spite of all that is said against the PPACA. By making it a political issue, the basic argument has been lost and its gravity is lessened in the eye of the common people.

1 of 13
A screen displays the Supreme Court's decision on healthcare on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange
A screen displays the Supreme Court's decision on healthcare on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange
drratanbhattacharjee is based in Kolkata, Bangla, India, and is a Reporter on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • House votes to repeal Affordable Care Act

      Tulsa World
    Since Republicans took control of the House in 2010, it has voted to repeal the health-care law more than 30 times, but the effort has never gotten any traction in the Democratic-controlled U.S...Speaker of the House John Boehner, R-Ohio, argued that...
  • Poll: Voters call health care mandate a tax

      USA Today
    The Quinnipiac University survey also delivers a mixed message on Obama's signature domestic achievement...The Supreme Court, in a 5-4 decision handed down June 28, upheld the health care law, including the mandate that requires nearly all Americans...
  • House Votes to Repeal Obama's Affordable Care Act

      Epoch Times
    July 11, 2012 The House of Representatives voted 244 to 185 Wednesday to again repeal the entirety of President Barack Obama's Affordable Care Act, further showing the deep rift between Democrats and Republicans in Congress. The measure will likely...
  • Republicans fall short on health care promises

    Even as they cheer their Obamacare repeal vote , here's a reality check: House Republicans have done next to nothing they promised they would when it comes to health care. Sure, they've voted to kill parts of President Barack Obama's law more than 30...
  • Nevada representatives reaffirm election year stances on health law

      Las Vegas Review-Journal / Sun
    Wednesday's vote to repeal the new health care overhaul enabled Nevada's U.S. House members to reaffirm their positions on the controversial law in advance of their fall campaigns...Joe Heck and Mark Amodei, Republican critics of the law, favored...
  • House votes to repeal health law

      Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
    The House voted Wednesday to repeal President Barack Obama's signature health care law, but don't cancel your medical appointments just yet. Republicans have tried some 30 times to repeal all or part of the law since it passed in 2010, providing...



More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.