The Affordable Health Act and Canadian Health Care Myths
Linkedin

The Affordable Health Act and Canadian Health Care Myths

Calgary : Canada | Jul 11, 2012 at 6:24 AM PDT
XX XX
Views: Pending
 
Oh. Canada?!

With the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling, holding the law as constitutional and the final vote cast by Chief Justice John Roberts, U.S. conservatives have taken to the blogs to discredit Canadian Health Care. The system may not be perfect, however it works for most of us in this country.

"Medicare is a Canadian success story. Not perfect, but good enough to be envied by much of the world.

Canadians now take it for granted they will receive high-quality health care when they need it, without financial or other barriers. In a country where we compare everything we do with what happens south of the border, we are surprised but pleased to find we have fashioned a health care program which delivers better care, with better results, to a much higher proportion of the population, at a much lower cost, than in the United States.

Confronted with these facts, policy-makers and the media have drawn the predictable conclusion: Canada's health care system is in crisis -- gravely ill at best, perhaps even on its death-bed." 10 Health Care Myths

Those opposed to Obamacare have described the long waiting lines, unavailabilty of physiscians as major problems of the Canadian system.

While there are some problems, some stories just make your hair stand up, especially when they refer to a province that you are very familiar with. One such story appeared on an American right-wing blog this morning. The author described a pilgrimage to an emergency room, during a blizzard because the pysician they had for 40 years had retired and they couldn't find a replacement. Thus the emergency room was a fact of life for them. The story reads like a novel that reminded me of people telling you how the walked five miles to school uphill both ways, in a snowstorm.

"The red light on the old alarm clock read 7:00. The morning news began with the top stories. It was the first Monday of the month, so my wife and I began our pilgrimage to the emergency clinic in Calgary, Canada. My extended family saw one doctor for 40 years; but because he retired and there are so few doctors in family practice, we now have to visit day clinics.

This particular Monday was during winter. A blizzard had rolled in off the Rocky Mountains, making the roads almost impassable. We felt strong enough to walk 3/4 of a mile in snow-driftedsidewalks to the clinic to get the prescriptions we need for Angie’s lupus and my asthma.

The real emergencies the clinic deals with every day are a shortage of doctors and waves of patients. Some of the patients, like us, just want a refill of a prescription; others are junkies, looking for a sympathetic doctor to give them their fix. Personal Liberty

There is actually an extensive list of physicians published by the College of Physicians and Surgeons in Alberta. While there is a shortage occasionally in rural areas, this is often corrected by hiring foreign physicians both in Saskatchewan and Alberta.

From a personal perspective, after retiring from the military I was confronted with finding a civilian doctor. Eventually my choice came down to three general practicioners, all accepting new patients. Just two years ago I changed doctors without any difficulty. The point here being that the physicians are out there if you take the time to look for them.

As people get older their reliance on healthcare increases. Alberta Health has good basic coverage and provides Blue Cross to its seniors, which covers a good portion of prescription needs. Politicians are held accountable for the delivery of health care and if they ignore the public's plea, they do it at their peril. Canadians expect good health care coverage. Are there isolated incidents of malpractice? You bet, but if you dig you can find the same problems in the United States under a private system.

Two of my friends recently lost their battle to cancer. In both cases the health care provided was second to none. There are a lot of myths promulgated about the Canadian Health Care system, but most of them are bogus and isolated incidents.

Take it from a Canadian, the coverage is more than adequate for the most part. The best part about the Canadian system is that you don't lose your shirt when you get sick. Fact check anything you read about the Canadian system. There are normally two sides to the story.

Let's face it most civilized nations provide health care for their citizens. Germany is case in point. The so-called socialist country, according to some, has combined capitalism with social programs, Their hospital system is such a combination. Article: Germany's Hospital System Works

If you like to write about U.S. politics and Campaign 2012, enter "The American Pundit" competition. Allvoices is awarding four $250 prizes each month between now and November. These monthly winners earn eligibility for the $5,000 grand prize, to be awarded after the November election.

Back
1 of 2
Next
U.S. President Obama walks away after delivering a statement about the Supreme Court's decision on his Administration's health care law at the White House in Washington
U.S. President Obama walks away after delivering a statement about the Supreme Court's decision on his Administration's health care law at the White House in Washington
Karl Gotthardt is based in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, and is an Anchor for Allvoices.
Report Credibility
 
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
 
 
Advertisement
 
Posted By firesisle Hardy Wright | 11 months ago
Karl,
"Take it from a Canadian, the coverage is more than adequate for the most part. The best part about the Canadian system is that you don't lose your shirt when you get sick. Fact check anything you read about the Canadian system. There are normally two sides to the story."

I don't doubt what you say. The problem with Obamacare is that it's poorly conceived and executed. The US could actually provide much better health care than Canada, and save a whole lot of money in the process(probably almost a half trillion dollars). Obamacare isn't universal health care; it's 2000+ pages of ideology and idiocy. Much of it doesn't even relate to health care but to pork promised to buy votes in the Senate. It's just bad legislation. We can do better...
Reply By albertacowpoke Karl Gotthardt | 11 months ago
Hardy I am aware of the problem with ObamaCare. Personally I think ur going to lose your shirt over it. When you add 23 Million to those that need to be insured and also add existing conditions something has to give since insurance company are not in business for a loss. Add to that all those that decide they don't need coverage, but get it when required, their $2400 fine will amount to a pittance of what health insurance premiums will be.

Yep 2700 pages for a law is crazy and of course nobody read the bill, probably including the Supreme Court.

Canada's health care is very expensive when you look at overall federal and provincial budgets. Making any changes to it is difficult, including providing some services through the private sector.

My point was to point out that a lot of the claims made by some are bogus. An article I read early this morning prompted me to write this.
Advertisement
 

News Stories

 
  • John Roberts' “Gold Lining” Moment

    Canadian Free Press
    Obama will have to defend a bad law, rather than run against a Supreme Court which could have made him appear a sympathetic victim and, therefore, his re-election more likely John Roberts' Gold Lining Moment Before everyone becomes too apoplectic and...
  • Physician, restrain thyself

    The Globe and Mail
    July, 2012 Doctors and nurses, both represented by powerful associations and unions, began to demand and receive very handsome wage settlements. From 1998 to 2008, physician compensation grew faster than the price of other services purchased by...
  • Doctors Hesitant To Deal With Patients' Weight Problems

    National Public Radio
    In 2010, there were 78 million adults classified as obese in the United States, and roughly 164,000 primary care doctors to take care of them. It doesn't take a math wizard to figure out that doctors who handle routine care, although they may well...
  • Biden rips Roberts (despite health care vote)

    USA Today
    Vice President Biden ripped Roberts in his speech yesterday to the National Council of La Raza, telling his largely Hispanic audience that Republican Mitt Romney wants to build a Supreme Court in the mold of conservative justices Roberts and Antonin...

Blogs

 >
  • Fareed's take: Obamacare and cutting healthcare costs – Global ...

    globalpublicsquare.blogs.cnn.com
    In Canada they consider 8 hours or less as a "A" grade, with some hospitals having 20+ hours wait time to get people into rooms (for example in Alberta only 59% of all cases were processed in under 8 hours). Wonderful .... Anyone who's
  • Medicare's 50th Anniversary: Canadian Health Care Under ...

    medicare50years.blogspot.com
    Emergency room overcrowding has reached crisis proportions in Ontario and Quebec; hospital closings have devastated rural communities in Saskatchewan and Alberta; the provinces are begging for federal health care cuts to be restored to ...
  • Chiropractic facts and the myths they dispel | www.ApnaHub.ca

    www.apnahub.ca
    From the Alberta College and Association of Chiropractors, here is a look at common myths about chiropractic and the facts that can dispel them. Myth: Chiropractors aren't real doctors. Fact: Health care legislation recognizes doctors of ...

Images

 >
 

More From Allvoices

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

 
Tap_logo_330_110_event
 


Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc 2008-2013. All rights reserved.