Can Luck Replace Manning?

Can Luck Replace Manning?

Indianapolis : IN : USA | Apr 19, 2012 at 12:43 PM PDT
Views: Pending
Peyton Manning Press Conference

The Colts announced today that they were going to draft Stanford QB Andrew Luck. We all knew they would. However, I believe this may be a HUGE mistake. Not the announcement, the draft choice. I don't have faith in Luck. Yes, he's been the Heisman Runner-Up for the last two years. But there's a reason is he's never won a big game.

A perfect example is this year's Oregon vs Stanford game. All Luck had to do was close the game, avoid throwing an interception, and run the clock. Yet he drops back and throws a beautiful pick six to lose the game. Had he avoided that mistake Stanford would have won and the BCS game would have been LSU vs Stanford. But they lost and played Oklahoma State in the Tostitos Fiesta Bowl, yet another game where Luck choked. And choking is one thing Jim Irsay does NOT deal with.

According to Irsay, Luck is the onewho's throwing style is most like Mannings. However, his ability to win, and to lead a high caliber offense in the fourth quarter is polar opposite of Mannings. One thing Manning did have, and still does, is his uncanny ability to come back in the second half. Which is one thing Luck lacks. The Colts also lost many veterans that could have helped Luck lead the offense, such as Saturday, Garçon, and Gonzalez.

I don't expect the Colts to have a good season with the rookie. People need to realize that although Andrew Luck may be good in college ball, the NFL is a completely different ball game. No pun intended. Everyone has way too high expectations for Andrew Luck. He’s just not good enough to be Peyton Manning's predecessor. In Colts minds all over the nation Manning is the best Quarterback to ever play in Indianapolis. The only way Luck can replace Manning is if he doubles the Super Bowl success of Manning. Even then I don’t know if Luck can get Manning out of everyone's mind. The blue and white number eighteen will forever be remembered in Indianapolis. I hope to see Denver play Luck in the near future.

With all of that I predict a 4-12 season.

1 of 21
Peyton Manning and Colts owner and CEO Jim Irsay leave a press conference announcing Manning's release from the Indianapolis Colts in Indianapolis
Peyton Manning and Colts owner and CEO Jim Irsay leave a press conference announcing Manning's release from the Indianapolis Colts in Indianapolis
ShayneCarnahan is based in Wyandotte, Oklahoma, United States of America, and is a Reporter on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Colts tell Stanford's Andrew Luck they'll take him No. 1 in NFL ...

      Big News Network
    The Indianapolis Colts have informed Stanford quarterback Andrew Luck that they will select him with the No. NFL Draft on April 26, the Indianapolis Star reported Thursday.The report makes official what had long been suspected: That team owner Jim...
  • AP source: Colts picking Andrew Luck at No. 1

      The Orange County Register
    A person with direct knowledge of the situation says the Indianapolis Colts are taking Stanford quarterback Andrew with the No...The team has informed Luck that he will replace Peyton Manning in Indy. The person spoke Thursday on condition of...
  • AP source: Colts picking Andrew Luck at No. 1

      Bradenton Herald
    Stanford quarterback Andrew Luck (12) celebrates after the Oct. 22 game against Washington. Luck has won the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award, presented annually to the nation's top quarterback who best exemplifies character and scholastic and athletic...
  • Report: Colts set to make Luck first pick in draft

    The Indianapolis Star cited an NFL source as saying the Colts have made their decision and have already informed Luck that he will be the top choice. NFL Network have also reported that Luck will be the Colts' pick. Colts general manager Ryan Grigson...
  • Kravitz: Colts will take Luck, then real work begins

      The Indianapolis Star
    The Indianapolis Colts have gone to Andrew Luck's pro day, they've done a private workout with the Stanford quarterback, and Luck was here in town last week for a long interview. The Colts have gone to Robert Griffin III's pro day, but Griffin's...
  • Colts keep quiet but make decision on No 1 pick

      AP Online
    The Indianapolis Colts have decided who to take with the No. They're just not planning to let the secret out until April 26. After months of speculation, scouting and scrutinizing, Colts general manager Ryan Grigson finally told...





More From Allvoices

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.