Pointless conflict

Pointless conflict

Gujrānwāla : Pakistan | Apr 09, 2012 at 3:28 PM PDT
Views: Pending
Tribute to Kargil War Heroes of Pakistan Army - Nation is Proud of You -

THE tragedy of over 130 Pakistani soldiers trapped under an avalanche has seen a massive search-and-rescue operation launched in the most difficult of terrains. Grim as the situation is, hope must not be given up. The round-the-clock effort could yield welcome results. Beyond the immediate tragedy, what the latest news from Siachen has done is to once again bring into focus the mindlessness of the Siachen conflict. Forty years ago, it was so improbable that the two countries could militarily face off in that inhospitable region that the Simla Agreement did not envisage demarcating the territory beyond the now infamous map coordinate known as NJ9842 when drawing the Line of Control. But after the Indian armed forces crept into Siachen in 1984 and moved on to the Saltoro Range to the west, Pakistan, alarmed that India had come so close to Skardu, sent its own troops up to the Saltoro Range. It is impossible to guess how many people have died in the conflict. Both sides closely guard the figures and independent estimates are impossible in an otherwise uninhabited area. But it is believed that the overwhelming number of casualties are caused by the altitude, cold and terrain.

What is obvious is that the conflict continues because of the obstinacy of the Indian Army. More than 20 years ago, Pakistani officials proposed a solution: the undemarcated areas under the Simla Agreement become zones of disengagement with both sides withdrawing their troops without prejudice to their pre-Siachen-conflict positions. However, because the Indian Army has captured territory that Pakistan claimed as its own and because all armies are loath to give up a military victory or advantage, however infinitesimal, the Indian Army insists that Pakistan accept its present positions as official, essentially demanding that Pakistan give up its claim to the territory.

Given the predominance of the Pakistan Army in national security and foreign policy here and the ill-advised choices it has made (Kargil is often cited by the Indian military as an example of why Pakistan cannot be trusted) it may seem that the Siachen conflict cannot be solved outside a broader settlement on Kashmir. However, a push by the Indian political side could see the objections of its armed forces overridden. After all, until recently it seemed like the Pakistan Army would never allow large-scale trade with India to be opened in the absence of a settlement on ‘core issues’.


1 of 5
Pakistan army vehicles drive near Siachen Glacier during search and rescue operations
Pakistan army vehicles drive near Siachen Glacier during search and rescue operations
Nimss is based in Daska, Punjab, Pakistan, and is a Reporter on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories



  • Avalanche buries 100 Pakistani troops in Kashmir | Nba Post Up

    They formalised the original ceasefire line as the Line of Control in the Simla Agreement, but this did not prevent further clashes in 1999 on the Siachen Glacier, which is beyond the Line of Control. India and Pakistan came close to war again ...
  • Pakistan - Paksir

    Anyhow, Siachen issue appeared on the list of Indo-Pak conflicts military authorities as a result of an expedition report came to know that Indian troops are occupying an undemarcated Pakistani area in 1984. It is very much true that Siachen had
  • Where there is no sun, there is fire « think big…write small

    It was then, when India and Pakistan first sent their military expeditions to the second largest non polar glacier 'Siachen' and crowned the area as the highest battlefield in the world. Many marched; many died…many wept and ... has
  • India Pakistan Relations Timeline: Aljazeera | Basix

    1972 - Pakistani Prime Minister Zulifiqar Ali Bhutto and Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi sign an agreement in the Indian town of Simla, in which both countries agree to "put an end to the conflict and confrontation that have hitherto marred
  • Indrakanti karthikeya: An Article and My Response!!

    Pakistan had sent touring expeditions to Siachen as early as 1957. Observing the indifferent attitude of the Indian Government, Pakistan had ... In 1971, 93000 soldiers of the same "predominant" army were captured by their Indian counter
  • Timeline: Flashpoints and flare-ups in India-Pakistan ties - Royce ...

    1965 - India and Pakistan fight their second war over Kashmir. Fighting ends after United Nations calls for ... 1972 - Pakistani Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto and Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi sign agreement in Indian town of Simla to lay



More From Allvoices

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.