Supreme court decision on Obama healthcare reforms is underway

Supreme court decision on Obama healthcare reforms is underway

Washington : DC : USA | Mar 26, 2012 at 11:36 PM PDT
Views: Pending
The Battle Continues in Wisconsin

As the Supreme Court enters the second day of reviewing Obama's health care reform that was signed into law exactly two years back, demonstrators gathered outside are in concensus that healthcare in America costs way too much.

Today, as the two hour session gets into progress, before deciding on the fate of the so-called Obamacare that was meant to provide better access to medical care while entending health insurance to some 30 million Americans, the Supreme Court will take a look at how the nine justices view of the present health reforms, that is still acting as a divide between the Republicans and the Democrats. A ruling in favor or against the healthcare reforms will play a pivotal role in the presidential elections in November this year.

The central issue surrounding Affordable Care Act is that by the year 2014, either most of the people will have to buy health insurance or will be liable to pay a tax penalty, in either case, they are worse of since the affordable care is not as affordable as initially promised. Moreover, the 26 states along with a small business state group challenging the law, argue that this health care plan is increasingly interferring with the lives of Americans by exceeding its authority to regulate the mandate.

In more general terms, those opposing the law say that if the governmet succeeds in forcing people into the buying health insurance, it would start gaining enough momentum to force people into other behaviours such as buying American made cars, which stocks to invest in, and for that matter which channels to watch and which cereal to take in breakfast on a particular day of the week.

On the other hand, Obama administration is of the opinion that since almost everyone is in need of health care at some point in their lives, choosing not to buy it will place unnecessary burden on an economy that is already facing its worst financial crisis ever.


On Monday, the two hour argument revolved around whether the chllenge by the 26 states is a premature one since the insurance requiremnt will not be enforced until 2014, and those who continue to opt for remaining uninsured wont have to pay penalties till early 2015.

The nine justices reviewing the matter are split in four liberals to five conservatives. The liberal appointed justices include, Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan. The conservative justices, who are also in majority, are Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Antonin Scalia, Anthony Kennedy, Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito. Most likely the libereras will be in favor of keeping the law intact and would need only one more conservative to win the case.

The final decison is expected to come by the end of June, while the audio recorrdings of the argument will be released the same day they take place.

1 of 31
People line up around the block, hoping to be allowed in to watch first day of legal arguments over Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act at Supreme Court in Washington
People line up around the block, hoping to be allowed in to watch first day of legal arguments over Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act at Supreme Court in Washington
Wendy Zachary is based in Texas, Texas, United States of America, and is a Reporter on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • 3 days of hearings over, 2 justices may be key

      The Tribune
    The four Democratic-appointed justices seemed to champion the law. If they all support it, at least one of the court's five Republican appointees would still be needed to uphold the law. Two of them, Justices Antonin Scalia and Samuel Alito, sounded...
  • Hard Questions From Conservative Justices Over Insurance Mandate

      The New York Times
    May failure to purchase something subject me to regulation? he asked...Roberts Jr. asked if the government could compel the purchase of cellphones...Alito Jr. asked about forcing people to buy burial insurance. The conventional view is that the...
  • Justices tackle heart of health care case

      The Columbus Dispatch
    Four of the Supreme Court's conservative justices today sharply questioned a Justice Department attorney about the new health law, signaling their skepticism about the government's claim that it can compel Americans to buy health insurance. In the...
  • Justices Split in Questions on Insurance Mandate

      The New York Times
    Opinion Predicting the result in any Supreme Court case, much less one that will define the legacies of a president and a chief justice, is nothing like a science, and the case could still turn in various directions. But the available evidence...
  • Justices Split on Severability Question

    The Supreme Court on Wednesday appeared to split down ideological lines on the question of which sections of President Barack Obama's health care law should survive if the individual mandate is struck down. The court's liberal wing -- Ruth Bader...
  • Supreme court moves to heart of Obama healthcare case

      Baltimore Sun
    The scheduled two-hour session promised to offer the first concrete look at how the court's nine justices view the law that Obama signed two years ago and that still divides hisDemocrats and rival Republicans. No past rulings are completely on point...





More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.