Kony 2012 & The Problem of Good Intentions

Kony 2012 & The Problem of Good Intentions

Lakeland : FL : USA | Mar 14, 2012 at 1:06 PM PDT
Views: Pending
AFRICOM = Reason for Kony 2012

I give them credit, the Invisible Children organization has done an exceptional job at bringing awareness to an issue which has long been shunned by society at large. This much could be agreed upon by even the staunchest critics of Invisible Children and its current campaign. But at what point does one’s positive and well-intended campaign become a force for something which is other than good? When does criticism (not to be confused with cynicism) become a force not of hindrance, but of focus and construction?

The leadership of Invisible Children and the Kony 2012 campaign have rightly insisted on the need to end all evil and injustice perpetrated by Kony and his LRA leadership. But—how does one accomplish this grand task? The IC have put forth a plan, and a rather ingenious one at that.

The website features a list of twenty “culture makers” and a list of twelve “policy makers” in which activists are encouraged to garner support from. The goal? After obtaining the necessary support, IC intends on forwarding military resources to Uganda with the intention of “arresting him, disabling the LRA, and bringing the child soldiers home.” Since the campaign video was released over a week ago, it has been viewed well over 78 million times on Youtube alone. But even with the phenomenal support, IC has also drawn harsh criticism among the activist community and from uneasy Ugandans who are much closer to the situation.

Rosebell Kagumire, a Ugandan native who commented on the campaign through a Youtube video, stated: “The war was more than just an evil man killing children, the war is much more complex than just one man called Joseph Kony. . . . This video seems to say that the power lays in America, and it does not lay with my government, it does not lay with local initiatives on the ground.

That aspect is lacking and this is the problem.” Another statement made by Javie Ssozi, also from Uganda, says “Suggesting that the answer is more military action is just wrong; have they thought of the consequences? Making Kony ‘famous’ could make him stronger. Arguing for more US troops could make him scared and make him abduct more children, or go on the offensive.”

It is here that we arrive at the distinction between good intentions and unintended consequences. Those who deem these “unintended consequences” as inconsequential to the greater goals of the movement—have also suggested that critics should not be critical, but should instead be pleased that so many around the globe are pursuing such a just and moral cause. They argue that the growth shift in popular activism is alone enough to justify the actions of the movement (in regards to any imperfections there might be). However, this should not be so. Such assertions are often the product of a strong emotional appeal which stirs immediate and impulsive action, which also, effectively discourages careful and learned rationalization. However, There appears to be a problem with activism in general: more often than not, there exists an abundance of heartfelt conviction and determination, but in that, rests little logical consideration to how the problem might best be solved—with these secondary conditions in mind.

There is also considerable discrepancy between facts and narrative implied by the Kony 2012 campaign and the actual state of affairs which Uganda currently maintains. As stated by Rosebell Kagumire: "Right now, Joseph Kony is not in Uganda. The situation in the video was five or six years ago. The situation has tremendously improved in Northern Uganda—people sleep at home, and . . . children are going to school, and it's about post-conflict recovery right now, and we don't see issues of—what needs to be done—especially when he puts Uganda at the center of this conflict."

What is truly ironic about this movement is its intent to “end a war” by method of direct military intervention. Do they really suppose that there will be no unintended consequences from this action? And of the child soldiers being used to oppose his capture and arrest—there is a significant chance that escalating force would further put these child soldiers in greater harm.

By affirming military force as the solution, It is likely that the child soldiers would tragically be found in the crosshairs of Invisible Children’s own cause. In this event, it should be noted (if it were to occur) that the outcome may not justify the means as it were intended. In this scenario and in many examples past, history would indicate that many well-intended people have pushed thoughtful agendas, only to discover in hindsight, that the outcome was worse—than if these individuals had simply maintained things as they were.

Consider the actions and results of the war in Iraq and even the rise of Marxian-Communism. Both of these projects began as seemingly selfless and morally good endeavors, but results would demonstrate that these events did not progress as expected. The intentions of direct intervention in Iraq were similar to that of the Kony 2012 campaign—that is, the removal of an evil person from power, so that the innocent can live free from harm and oppression. Ironically though, the resulting instability in Iraq has been thoroughly worse than the murder and tyranny which existed under Saddam Hussein.

Such is the danger that one risks by promoting an agenda purely based on good intentions. Uganda is in a state of rebuilding, and like Iraq, military intervention might deconstruct the rebuilding process, and create a larger conflict than what currently exists.

Kony 2012 activists would do well to consider the concerns of their critics. In open-minded examination, both activists and critics may very well find themselves on the same side of the issue. Many, if not most of the critics wish to achieve the same goal—they have simply examined these goals while accounting for the unintended consequences which may result.

1 of 6
Joseph Kony
Joseph Kony
benjithompson is based in Orlando, Florida, United States of America, and is a Stringer on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Africa: Kony's Dubious First for the Continent

      All Africa
    The need for a better campaign" captured well the sympathies many felt for the victims of Joseph Kony's atrocities upon watching the video. It also elaborated on the disappointments, one of them being that the video was outdated despite a touching...
  • Teacher in Uganda: Why give celebrity status to a killer in Kony 2012?

      Christian Science Monitor
    As a high school teacher, I grapple with the Kony 2012 video and horrific memories it stirs for my students. Foreigners again look at Uganda as a country of misery, ignoring our progress. We defeated Kony and the LRA rebels. Why not make a video...
  • Kony screening provokes anger in Uganda

      Al Jazeera
    25 Joseph Kony is a household name, thanks to a 30-minute YouTube video raising awareness about his brutal rebel group, the Lord's Resistance Army (LRA). Tens of millions have seen the video after US charity, Invisible Children, released the clip...
  • 'Kony' video reaches many young adults

      United Press International
    American adults ages 18-29 were much more likely than older adults to have heard of the popular documentary "Kony 2012," a survey said. The Pew Research Center survey also found the younger adults were much more likely to have heard about the video...
  • 'Stop Kony' screening tour cancelled after Ugandans react with outrage

      The Globe & Mail
    Video Video Video The video by a California-based activist group had already been strongly criticized by many African writers and Western aid experts, who called it simplistic, patronizing and inaccurate. They are worried that the publicity will...
  • Ugandan PM makes his own film about Kony and the viral video

      Sydney Morning Herald
    A video produced by the US-based Invisible Children group about Kony and his brutal Lord's Resistance Army has been viewed over 100 million times on social media sites. "The campaign has not just been an impressive indication of the power of social...





More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.