Ryan Giggs' cheek suit flushed

Ryan Giggs' cheek suit flushed

Norwich : United Kingdom | Mar 02, 2012 at 9:14 AM PST
Views: Pending
Ryan Giggs 900 not out for Manchester United
The High Court in England has thrown out what might go down in history as the most desperate and debauched damages claim ever to engage that court’s attention. The claim – heard by Mr Justice Tugendhat in a London Court last month – was made by Manchester United and Wales footballer Ryan Giggs against Rupert Murdoch’s Sun newspaper. Counsel for Giggs, Hugh Tomlinson QC , claimed that The Sun “’misused” private information and argued that Giggs “was entitled to claim damages for distress and breach of a right to privacy enshrined in human rights legislation”, according to the Press Association. Responding The Sun argued that the footballer’s claim – arising from its publication of an article about Giggs’ alleged sexual congress with reality television star Imogen Thomas – is “dead in the water” and should be stopped. We might speculate that if Sun representative Richard Spearman QC had argued that Giggs’ claim was “dung in the water” and should be flushed, Mr Justice Tugendhat might have given the same judgement today. This purely speculative and arguably inconsequential question turns, we may suppose, on Mr. Spearman’s need (or not) in every instance to satisfy the rigorous legal labelling requirements of jurisprudence. The decorum or propriety of going with “dead” over “dung” may also be a consideration. Beyond question though, in Mr. Justice Tughendat’s mind, apparently, is the expiration of any legal sustenance or nutritional value Giggs’ claim may have had. In this writer’s mind and conceivably in the collective conscious space that is public opinion, the lack of logic or morality in Giggs’ attempt to assign responsibility to the Sun for the “large media storm” that was supposedly generated by its article about his affair with Ms. Thomas – in which he was not named – is patent. Only in Giggs mind, perhaps (one would like to think that Mr. Tomlinson and his other legal advisors tried to talk him out of the action), could the fact that his name recognition (alluded to but protected by the Sun) was the indisputable catalyst for the fevered response to the article in Britain and around the world be overlooked. As Mr. Spearman said, the Sun reported on “Ms Thomas's relationship with a Premier League player and did not identify Giggs.” The Sun behaved "properly", he said and “was not responsible for what happened after the article appeared.” Only the famous footballer family man, perhaps, could convince himself that the European Convention on Human Rights’ provision of “effective protection" for his right to privacy should trump the Sun’s right to freely report the news and Imogen Thomas’ freedom of conscience. Mr. Giggs is probably best advised to reconcile himself to the beauty and terror of being famous. In a written judgement today, Mr Justice Tugendhat refused “to grant relief” to Giggs. Such relief as Mr. Giggs is likely to receive or achieve will probably come through his own inward, private digestion and reconciliation of fame’s potential profit and loss. It probably will not come from further parading the spectacle of his infidelity through the law courts.

(Writer's note: this story was originally etitled "Ryan Giggs' sh_t suit flushed" but I decided to err on the side of cauti of caution: wouldn't want it to be "flagged" and flushed.

1 of 19
Manchester United's Ryan Giggs
Manchester United's Ryan Giggs
Junior Campbell is based in London, England, United Kingdom, and is an Anchor on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Ryan Giggs damages claim rejected

    Ryan Giggs loses damages claim against the Sun Ryan Giggs took out an injunction against the Sun newspaper and TV presenter Imogen Thomas A damages claim by Manchester United and Wales footballer Ryan Giggs against the Sun newspaper has been thrown...
  • Judge ends 'notorious' Ryan Giggs legal action

      The independent
    The Bedouin of Israel and the occupied territories are easy to pick on...Suggested Topics A High Court judge today blew the final whistle on "notorious" legal action launched by Manchester United and Wales footballer Ryan Giggs against The Sun. Giggs...
  • Judge rejects Ryan Giggs' privacy claim against The Sun

      The Independent
    The Bedouin of Israel and the occupied territories are easy to pick on...Suggested Topics A damages claim by Manchester United and Wales footballer Ryan Giggs against the Sun newspaper was thrown out by a High Court judge today. Giggs claimed that...
  • Ryan Giggs loses battle for Sun damages

      The Observer
    Ryan Giggs had alleged that News Group Newspapers misused private information. Photograph: Jed Leicester/Action Images Ryan Giggs has failed in a high court bid for damages and a permanent injunction against the Sun , following an article about an...
  • Giggs finally loses case over affair privacy

      The Independent
    India's Naxalite rebels need to be tackled with mainstream political activity, not just development ... Suggested Topics The footballer Ryan Giggs yesterday lost his long-running legal claim over the privacy dispute last summer that led to his being...
  • Hot pink! Imogen Thomas hides her blushes in a bright dress out on the town

      Mail Online UK
    Imogen Thomas dress matches her blushes as she goes out in a floaty dress on a very windy day Last updated at 11:18 AM on 4th March 2012 It seems Imogen Thomas has forgotten the cardinal rule of wearing a floaty dress on a windy day. The model...


  • FitbaThatba: Ryan Giggs is bad at court

    Ryan Giggs lost a battle with The Sun today over damages he wants from them for something to do with that story about the time he banged Imogen Thomas a lot and his wife wasn't happy about it. The sexually prolific home wrecker took on ...
  • On this day: Ryan Giggs makes his debut, 1991

    On this day: Ryan Giggs makes his debut, 1991. Soccer - Barclays Premier League - Norwich City vs. Manchester United Ryan Giggs. You are old. I'm often told that using the first person is bad form, and should only be used sparingly. I totally ...



More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.