The Catholic Church vs. Obama: outcry over contraceptives but silence on pedophile priests
Linkedin

The Catholic Church vs. Obama: outcry over contraceptives but silence on pedophile priests

Washington : DC : USA | Feb 12, 2012 at 8:27 PM PST
XX XX
Views: Pending
 
child sex abuse in Boston RC church

Commentary

President Obama's recent ruling on contraceptives ignited a swift backdraft from the Catholic Church and conservatives everywhere. Headlines of Obama driving Catholics to the Right abounded. Presidential candidate Rick Santorum upped the ante with his outrageous "Obama sending Christians to the guillotine" statement.

Abortion is another high-octane topic, and the Roman Catholic Church still stands on the side of it being morally wrong. Same with the use of birth control. The stunning paradox seems to have eluded them for centuries, and the modern Church has not relented on what they must know is "oxymoronic."

I understand forbidding their "flock" from exercising control over their bodies and reproductive life--that kind of power is heady. But this is 2012 and the argument that both abortion and birth control are wrong defies logic on every level.

Conservatives love to malign those on government assistance, those "baby mammas" sponging on the system while continuing to have children. So how do you prevent unwanted pregnancies? Last time I checked, it was sound common sense to protect oneself if one is not ready financially, emotionally or otherwise, to have a baby. If one does not protect oneself, chances are almost 100 percent, one will get pregnant eventually.

Abortion is a woman's right to choose. The legal battle has already been won though the ultra-right is fighting hard to undermine that right. Now if a woman cannot use birth control and also cannot have an abortion, what exactly are her options?

National cancer charity Susan B. Komen the Foundation for the Cure "defunded" Planned Parenthood recently and had to back-peddle when the backlash was instantaneous and harsh. They have since apologized, fired a few execs and restored existing funding to PP. Many saw the defunding move as "right-wing maneuvering"--politics trumping women's health.

Meanwhile, the rhetoric continues to ratchet up high but that sick perversion of child sexual abuse by priests in hiding behind those church walls do not garner not one percent of that public condemnation.

The hypocrisy is galling and oh so offensive to hear the loud chatter about birth control and abortion while not a whisper about the sickness of pedophilia entrenched in the Roman Catholic Church.

Why is that?

Why no loud outcry over the 200 priests who are under investigation for allegedly sexually abusing children in California and who still live within a mile of schools, playgrounds, daycare centers--within easy access to children?

Why no widespread public protests against the over 37 priests in Philadelphia who are charged with abusing children, 21 of whom were allowed to remain on active duty after the Church knew of the abuse allegations? Or those who systematically abused Native American and children in Washington and Alaska for decades?

Where is the moral outrage from the good people of the church? Those like Santorum who are very vocal about contraceptives, abortion and homosexuality being morally wrong?

Where is the outrage?

Back
1 of 12
Next
Rampant child sex abuse in Boston RC Church
VeronicaS is based in New York City, New York, United States of America, and is an Anchor for Allvoices.
Report Credibility
 
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
 
 
Advertisement
 
Posted By magyart magyart | over 1 year ago
The federal govt. must not force anyone to fund abortions, when they believe this is murder. Of course too many women refuse to admit abortion is the murder of an unborn child. If you want it, pay for it. Don't force me (as an employer) or the Church to pay for it.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
You can believe what you choose to believe but I would like to see some outrage about the children who are alive and here with us now who are being destroyed by sexual predators masquerading as men of God--and who the Church keeps hiding and protecting..
Posted By jimiham James A. Hamilton | over 1 year ago
As usual the GOP is really making a fuss over a non-issue to excite their base, that will end in mobilizing women and others about these and other issues the Catholic Church's heads have been shamed by, as you point out here.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
I couldn't agree more but it is so offensive and dangerous. For women in poor countries are being told by the Pope that it is wrong to use contraceptives and other birth control devices when AIDS is a rampant killer.
Posted By firesisle Hardy Wright | over 1 year ago
Veronica,
Clearly, both are wrong... what's you point? Are you saying that we should punish one stupidly wrong act with another?

"Now if a woman cannot use birth control and also cannot have an abortion, what exactly are her options?"

Don't be a Catholic. Religion has law and dogma, each unique, and the participation of each protected by the Constitution.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
I think my point is clear to any rational person Hardy. Clear to any want who finds the hypocrisy stunning here. It is morally wrong for a woman to protect herself from unwanted pregnancies and it is also wrong to have an abortion? Yet priests have been raping children for centuries and there is no public outcry from these same self-righteous blow-hearts?
Posted By dhreff dhreff | over 1 year ago
Veronica, yes, yes, the photo is very satirical. Catholic Church must close mouth when it cannot propose better alternatives to existing methods of population control. Rate you up.

Please see my "Obama presidency overshadows slave image of Black America".
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
Thanks for loving the pic Dhreff. Until the day they can have babies--they need to stop telling me what is morally wrong and take a look at the mounting dirt on their side.
Reply By magyart magyart | over 1 year ago
dhreff, Yr location is Olongapo :: Philippines. Do you have a "horse in this race" ? Might you be an employee of a religious organization, subject to laws in the USA ? Are you Catholic ? Might you need an abortion ? Adhere to the US Constitution ?
Reply By firesisle Hardy Wright | over 1 year ago
The Catholic Church, and it's members, not only must not close it's mouth, but is entitled to set the laws and canon of their religion, which is binding to those who practice it. That right to privacy is also protected by the ruling of Wade vs. Roe, which dictated that there are areas of an individual's life and choices, into which the government may not intrude. It's akin to creating a law which would require Jews or Muslims to eat pork. Basically a no-brainer.

The Catholic Church has no responsibility to change the nature of it's religious practices to appease liberal sensibilities; as much as I abhor the practice of abortion, I will always vehemently support the findings of Wade vs. Roe, because they provide protections for all citizens, regardless of their political proclivity.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
Hardy, i don't want the RC Church to change their laws to appease Liberal sensibilities---I want them to stop the raping of children by their "men of God."--Stop hurting and destroying innocent lives. Stop protecting those sick predators lurking under those robes. I want them to stop the high hypocrisy of holding unto archaic laws that hurt women around the world--especially in poor nations of Africa--stop telling women it is morally wrong to control their own bodies and protect themselves from unwanted pregnancies.

That is what's morally reprehensible--the climate of control, cover-up and blatant hypocrisy, not birth control.
Posted By Punditty Punditty | over 1 year ago
A well-timed look at the picture of the "pregnant" GOP hopefuls accompanying this article just might prove to be the most effective birth control of all time.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
Hahaha! Punditty, you never fail to make me laugh out loud and i think you just may be on to something!
Posted By dhreff dhreff | over 1 year ago
Veronica, did I start it all with my "Catholic Church must close mouth...". Well this is the beauty of interactive communication. We learn from one another. The pebble minded and those who are easily irritated will always be the losers in this kind of calisthenics. I enjoy interacting with you Veronica.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
Thank you Dhreff. We can all have a conversation on issues that affect us as human beings. Priests molest children all over the globe, not just here in the U.S.
Posted By jasonllsworth jasonllsworth | over 1 year ago
Great article, Veronica. I was stunned when the Penn State pedophilia scandal broke and a national frenzy followed. Where is the outrage over the eleven thousand victims of catholic priests in the U.S.? Why does this organization even still exist? The world should have come together long ago and closed the doors of the vatican forever. Bishops, cardinals, and priests have all conspired together to rape children in the tens of thousands all over the world, and sweep it under the rug. The pope has known about this filth for decades, and is therefore just a dirty old man himself. This behavior demonstrates what religion does to the mind of humans. It shuts down ration and logic, and becomes a form of mental sickness. Evidently, women are just for making babies, and the man in the frock is god's gift to help her understand her 'place'.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | over 1 year ago
Thanks for commenting Jason--I couldn't have said it better. Like you, I am stunned by the world's apathy over the systematic raping of children all over the world. You are right, religion can turn us into blind, irrational beings. Our silence is consent.
Posted By PeteV PeteV | about 1 year ago
I do see your point above about the Catholic church covering up molesters. This is truly sadening. Be that as it may, it still does not take away the fact that a church organization should not be forced to have to pay or fund birth control be it in the form of a pill or an abortion.

You have to remember that just as women fought to have the Gov't not control what to do with their own bodies, these members of church organizations should not be forced by that same government to pay for something they do not believe in.

You cannot make all the people happy all the time, but if things like abortion and contraception are choices then make it a private and personal choice, not a Federal Gov't mandate.

PS - I am not a Catholic but I have heard quite a bit of coverage on Catholic priests disturbing behaviour on many occasions. I would not say that this has been ignored by any measure.
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | about 1 year ago
Thanks for commenting. I am not talking about reporting priests raping of children, I am talking prosecution. How many priests have you heard of who were prosecuted-- legally punished for their crimes?

No, the government should not force the church to pay but if they get funding and tax exemption from said government, that changes the dynamics.
Posted By DanielHaszard DanielHaszard | about 1 year ago
Please examine the Jehovah's Witnesses who go door to door and come on our property.

Jehovah's Witnesses pedophiles.

Many court documents and news events prove that Jehovah's Witnesses require two witnesses when a child comes forward with allegations of molestation within the congregation. Such allegations have customarily been treated as sins instead of crimes and are only reported to authorities when it is required to do so by law, (which varies by state). It has also been shown that child molesters within the organization usually have not been identified to the congregation members or the public at large.
These people engage in a door to door ministry, possibly exposing children to pedophiles.
Although the Watchtower Bible Tract Society claims that known pedophiles are accompanied by a non-pedophile in such work, there is no law stating that such a practice must be followed.
The Watchtower corporation has paid out millions in settlement money already.
--
Danny Haszard abuse victim

http://dannyhaszard.com/sexabuse/index.htm
Reply By VeronicaS VeronicaS | about 1 year ago
Thanks for shedding some light on another church's crimes against children and your own personal pain. Child sexual abuse exist in many corners of our society and we need to speak out as loudly or even louder than we are about other issues that do not warrant half the energy put into it.
Advertisement
 

News Stories

 
  • The Culture Wars Make a Comeback in 2012 Election

    Fox
    The immortal campaign words from the 1990s, "It's the economy, Stupid," were thought to apply to the campaign season of 2012, too. But recent circumstances have re-ignited the culture wars and help to explain the sudden and unlikely rise of Rick...
  • In an election about the economy, the culture wars make a comeback

    Fox News
    The immortal campaign words from the 1990s, "It's the economy, Stupid," were thought to apply to the campaign season of 2012, too. But recent circumstances have re-ignited the culture wars and help to explain the sudden and unlikely rise of Rick...
  • Obama chief of staff: No more compromise, contraceptive rule is done deal

    Fox News
    Despite renewed statements of concern by Catholic leaders, the Obama administration is done negotiating and will finalize its plan requiring insurance companies to provide free contraception to women working and studying at religious institutions,...
  • Some issues may hurt Santorum with women

    United Press International
    Earlier today, Santorum was in Olympia meeting with a church group opposed to gay marriages. He also met with the state House and Senate Republican caucuses. Feb. 15 (UPI) -- Republican U.S. presidential hopeful Rick Santorum 's weak appeal among...
  • A valentine for Komen

    Washington Post
    On Valentine's Day last year, my father called to say that his wife Susan's long struggle with breast cancer was over. The love of his life, my stepmother of more than 30 years, took her last breath on a hospital bed at Nancy Brinker, founder and...
  • Miller: Going medieval on birth control

    Summit Daily News
    Catholic bishops and the shrieking Right will tell you this whole business about requiring even church-run businesses to provide contraception as part of their health care plan is an attack on religion. They're wrong, although with the economy...

Blogs

 >

Images

 >
 

More From Allvoices

Related People

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

 
Tap_logo_330_110_event
 


Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc 2008-2013. All rights reserved.