HP's WebOS Failure Proves It's Hard to Be Like Apple

HP's WebOS Failure Proves It's Hard to Be Like Apple

Avondale : AZ : USA | Aug 21, 2011 at 5:54 AM PDT
Views: Pending
HP TouchPad for $100!

With HP's decision to stop making WebOS phones and tablets, one thing is painfully clear: Being like Apple is tougher than it looks.

Apple CEO Steve Jobs famously said that his company "creates the whole widget," from hardware to software to services. By comparison, hardware makers like Dell, Samsung and Lenovo are at the whim of Microsoft and Google, who respectively license their Windows and Android operating systems and don't build any hardware themselves. In recent years, Apple's strategy has worked out beautifully. Even though Android has more market share than the iPhone, Apple makes more money from smartphones than any other hardware maker.

(MORE: Google, Motorola and HP: How the Tech Industry Is Changing)

So when HP acquired Palm and its WebOS software last year for $1.2 billion, the strategy made a lot of sense. After years of building Windows laptops and desktops, HP wanted its own widget to control. In February, the company announced a pair of new phones and the TouchPad, a WebOS tablet. HP also spoke of bringing WebOS to printers, automobiles and even home appliances like stoves and refrigerators.

But HP's execution was flawed. According to The Next Web, Palm's tablet hardware was already in the pipeline when HP acquired the company. And from the looks of it, Palm's smartphone plans were set in stone as well. Instead of releasing WebOS hardware with fresh new designs, HP launched a teeny smartphone (the Veer), a chunky tablet (the TouchPad) and yet another spec boost for the Pre (the still-unreleased Pre 3), whose predecessors never sold particularly well in the first place. Also, HP didn't control quite as much widget as Apple, because it was still relying on other companies to build its processors.Since the iPad and iPhone 4, Apple has designed its own chips.

Even worse, HP failed to cultivate a decent ecosystem of apps. It's hard to find an official count, but I've seen recent estimates of between 8,000 and 10,000 WebOS apps, and that's more than two years after Palm launched the first WebOS phone. Microsoft's Windows Phones, by comparison, hit 11,700 apps in less than one year. I offer Windows Phones as an example because, like WebOS, they haven't been a huge hit, but developer interest remains strong.

To top it all off, the TouchPad was buggy and sluggish at launch. Although a software update later alleviated some the TouchPad's issues, reviewers could only critique what they were given: an unfinished product.

Turns out, controlling the whole widget is a massive undertaking. After acquiring Palm, HP suddenly had to create innovative hardware, squash bugs from its software and encourage developers to build cool apps. In the case of smartphones, they also had to build relationships with wireless carriers, who ultimately subsidize and sell handsets to consumers. All of that is a huge leap from installing Windows on laptops and PCs and shipping them out the door. If no one's buying the product, why bother with all that effort?

Strictly from a financial standpoint, controlling hardware, software and services is the way to go. Companies who do so get to control their own destiny, as Ben Bajarin put it, while also reaping all of the rewards. But in the smartphone and tablet market, I've yet to see evidence that anyone but Apple can pull it off. Palm failed, which is why it had to be sold to HP in the first place. Research in Motion is struggling. Nokia gave up on its MeeGo OS and is now working closely with Microsoft. Google plans to acquire Motorola, but promises to keep Android open while running the hardware company as a separate entity.

I'm not saying that Apple's the only company that can control the whole widget, but right now, no one else can be bothered to put in the effort.

Read more: http://techland.time.com/2011/08/19/hps-webos-failure-proves-its-hard-to-be-like-apple/#ixzz1VfCBfKOm

1 of 7
WebOS was designed by Palm for smartphones but HP, which bought Palm last year, plans on using it in computers
WebOS was designed by Palm for smartphones but HP, which bought Palm last year, plans on using it in computers
Ahsan alijunaid is based in Faisalābād, Punjab, Pakistan, and is a Stringer on Allvoices.
Report Credibility
  • Clear
  • Share:
  • Share
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear
  • Clear

News Stories

  • Comes the "post-PC era"

      Turks. US
    Central Daylight Time Time seems to agree with ominous Steve Jobs, Apple guru, who in 2010 prophesied the advent of "post-PC era", a cyclical change in the way people consume technology and presaged by IBM that has joined this week Hewlett-Packard (...
  • With HP tablet dead, who can challenge Apple?

      The Economic Times
    The sudden demise of Hewlett-Packard Co's WebOS TouchPad after just seven weeks on shelves was a reminder of how tech giants have failed so far to take a bite out of Apple Inc's iPad. The TouchPad joins Dell Streak 5 in the tablet graveyard and weak...
  • HP Discontinues Touchpad – Finds taking a bite out of Apple too hard to ...

      International Business Times
    HP reported that it plans to announce that it will discontinue operations for webOS devices, specifically the TouchPad and webOS phones. HP will continue to explore options to optimize the value of webOS software going forward. Must Read HP Press...
  • HP's webOS: It's Not the End After All

      International Business Times
    Stay connected with cutting edge technology news Sample Nonetheless, there are reports fluttering around that HP is having plan for licensing webOS. "We're looking at all business models, from licensing to any other possibility for webOS," Apotheker...
  • Think HP is going to be able to license WebOS? Think again

      Guardian Unlimited
    Think again WebOS is was a great little operating system, but the arguments against it being licensed are overwhelming HP TouchPad running WebOS: not coming to a device near you any time soon Already there is plenty of talk about the possibility of...
  • What if Microsoft bought Hewlett-Packard’s PC business?

      Seattle Post Intelligencer
    Microsoft news and other technology news, photos, charts and data from seattlepi.com. (Base unicorn image by scorpiorules58/Flickr) Let's take a trip to Never Ever Land. A land of where unicorns roam, where pigs fly and where Microsoft acquired the...



More From Allvoices

Report Your News Got a similar story?
Add it to the network!

Or add related content to this report

Most Commented Reports

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use Agreement and Privacy Policy.

© Allvoices, Inc. 2008-2014. All rights reserved. Powered by PulsePoint.